3 ms·
I'm very worried that as services revenue becomes important, the aggressive rent-seeking behaviour from Apple will only increase and they'll start damaging user
by izacus 6y ago
I'm very worried that as services revenue becomes important, the aggressive rent-seeking behaviour from Apple will only increase and they'll start damaging user experience even more.
Heck, iOS 14 booted with an Ad notification and in settings to buy their subscription services.
- peterwoerner 6y agoIt feels, to me, that a duopoly is worse for the consumer than a monopoly. Monopolies behave better due to fear of regulation, but in a duopoly's justify their own bad behaviour based on the their counter-party.
- newsclues 6y agoBoth duopolies and monopolies can benefit from regulatory capture, and need not always fear regulation, especially if they can have undue influence on regulators.
- wsc981 6y agoThe Apple music subscription advertising in the Music app is annoying as hell as well.
- easton 6y agoYou can disable this in Settings -> Music -> Show Apple Music if you want to.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dilap 6y agoIt blows my mind that the top search result for an app is often an ad for a different app. You know that gazillions of unsophisticated users are downloading the wrong app as a result and having a worse experience. (It's easy to do as a sophisticated user if you're not paying attention!) Apple directly selling out UX for $ is certainly not an optimistic sign. I do wonder at a much broader level if there's some way to structure society to bring the motivation & focus that young companies give us w/o the inevitable slide to evil that capitalism and investors demand.
- gwright 6y ago> the aggressive rent-seeking behaviour from Apple Can you clarify what you mean here? I associate the term "rent-seeking" with efforts to manipulate public policies in a way that advantages the company specifically over other competitors. You seem to be talking about an ecosystem "lock-in" approach, which is something different than "rent-seeking".
- vlovich123 6y agoThe Wikipedia definition is probably closest: > rent-seeking means seeking to increase one's share of existing wealth without creating new wealth I think the distinction is probably phrased as seeking to increase one’s share of wealth without providing a commensurate amount of value in return.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoAt least some of their services have competition - netflix, spotify are both bigger (I believe?) than Apple's competition. It could drop quickly for Spotify if Apple decides to ban them from the app store like they did Fortnite, which will in part depend on Spotify trying to get around the App Store fees like Epic did. And things could change drastically if the lawsuits currently springing up against Apple's fees and monopolies end up successful. But then, it'll likely mean "Apple makes less profit" than "Apple is destroyed". Remember, Apple has nearly $200 billion in cash, as well as a 20% profit margin. They pump a lot of money into R&D (nearly $20 billion a year, still climbing every year). Basically they're very secure, financially speaking.
- r00fus 6y agoInternal advertising of their services is not "agressive rent-seeking". Lets come up with valid examples to compare/contrast.
- musicale 6y ago> iOS 14 booted with an Ad notification and in settings to buy their subscription services. I really hate Apple's spammy advertising; it seriously damages the user experience (not to mention Apple's reputation and brand) for no good reason. Obviously spammy and obnoxious advertising works to some extent or companies wouldn't do it - but user goodwill takes years to build up and probably shouldn't be sacrificed on the altar of short-term monetization. If Apple's services are actually good, then users shouldn't need to be spammed with obnoxious alerts and preinstalled adware. It should simply be an optional (and opt-in) add-on that's included in the box like a "free" code for a year of service if you want - and I think they do that already for Apple TV+ and Apple Arcade. If it's worth it, people will renew. Word of mouth and regular non-spammy advertising should do the rest.