3 ms·
"Rendering the federal government impotent" is a good thing in the eyes of the ~50% of the US that lives outside your filter bubble. Having a strong federal go
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
"Rendering the federal government impotent" is a good thing in the eyes of the ~50% of the US that lives outside your filter bubble.
Having a strong federal government is not the settled matter you seem to imply it is.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoDepends what you mean by settled matter. In discussion, I'm sure you can find a lot of people that think it's a bad idea, and I'm ambivalent myself. But as a matter of reality a strong federal government is what we now have. I think the federal government and the executive in particular is much stronger than the founders thought it would ever be.
- rayiner 6y agoBut it doesn’t have to be that way. Other countries have maintained a robust federalism. (Canada has 80% of total spending at the provincial level, versus our 50%.) Some countries like Sweden which are unitary reformed to push more decisions and spending down to the provincial level. Some unitary countries like Spain are exploring it: https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/resource/federalism-may-save-spain-from-itself/ https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/resource/federalism-...
- tastyfreeze 6y agoThe federal government absolutely has more power than was intended. The constitution only allows the federal government to do very specific things. This includes the power to coin money, to regulate commerce, to declare war, to raise and maintain armed forces, and to establish a Post Office. Everything else is left to the states. How many powers does the federal government have that are above those enumerated powers? The government we have is not what the constitution defines. It is what the constitution was designed to prevent. But, we have slowly marched towards a central government that the founders feared and warned needed to be protected against. A central government has a much higher risk of tyrannical control.
- michaelmrose 6y ago99% of the Democrats and 98% of the republicans including present leadership disagree with your assessment. If your position weakens any further it wont even have one seat in congress. In a democracy a position that virtually nobody cares for is dead.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoTrusting the people to hold the government to the Constitution may have been the fatal flaw. I know that being a Constitutional idealist is a weak position. I feel that is very unfortunate. The Constitution was intended to protect against human natures of avarice and corruption and limit to paths to tyrannical government. Every time the Constitution is weakened the paths to corruption and tyranny are widened.
- michaelmrose 6y agoAllowing a minority of welfare states to extract the money and blood of the united states while voting in their representative to oversee the extraction literally weakens the constitutional protections afforded to everyone as we have seen in the last 20 years.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoWouldn't an appropriate response to welfare bleeding the coffers be to stop the welfare? It obviously cannot be controlled. edit: removed "properly" as I don't think there is a proper way to control welfare.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoThread is dead but I want to add that it isn't a minority of welfare states. There are only 11 states that pay more in federal taxes than they spend in federal benefits. https://www.businessinsider.com/federal-taxes-federal-services-difference-by-state-2019-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/federal-taxes-federal-servic...
- JamesBarney 6y agoThis is true in the sense of if you ask someone "Should the federal government be smaller?" they will say yes. It is not true in the "Should we get rid of Medicare and Social Security and reimplement them on a state by state basis?" or "Should we abolish the FCC, SEC, EPA, FDA, Postal Service?" When you ask people if we should make the federal government smaller they'll say yes, when you ask them about a specific piece of the federal government they say no.
- michaelmrose 6y agoIn order to reverse the trend you have to have people who are the very representatives of the power you wish dismantled choose to dismantle it. This is even harder than it seems. The job naturally predominantly attracts those who desire the power in the first place and they retain the support of the people who put and keep them there by giving these people things they desire. This is why you see tax cuts but no real meaningful reduction of the federal government. You might as well consider it an axiom that no government willingly dis empowers itself. You say its not settled but it has been moving the same direction for 244 years and shows no sign of reversing course. What suggests a reversal to you?