4 ms·
Apple doesn't love you back. Amazon doesn't love you back. Any company that seems oh-so-awesome, but makes their software proprietary, does not love you back.
by rglullis 6y ago
Apple doesn't love you back. Amazon doesn't love you back. Any company that seems oh-so-awesome, but makes their software proprietary, does not love you back.
You are never going to fix the problem of centralization of wealth if you keep thinking that is a matter of "unfairness". (Much like Socialism and central planning), as long as people give in their freedoms to big central entities for the immediate benefit they offer (shiny hardware, low TCO, whatever) economies of scale lock-in and then it becomes almost impossible to get these entities back under control.
As long as there are people that think that it is okay for us to spend our resources creating private software we will get companies exploiting trying to extract value from software developers, and especially so from those that work on FOSS
- eru 6y agoI thought free software was all about allowing people to create value from it?
- rglullis 6y agoEven though I believe it is more about the principles than the economics, where am I saying otherwise? The problem I am talking about is the asymmetry: Apple (Amazon, Google, MS, etc) can create value from the work from FOSS developers, but FOSS developers can not create value from the work of Apple (Amazon, Google, MS, etc).
- sokoloff 6y agoI would say that developers have been able to create a lot of value building on top of Android (Google), Flutter (Google), and .Net Core (Microsoft). I could probably dig up specifically an Amazon open source example, but I think you can convincingly argue that devs have created a ton of value building on top of the work on AWS.
- rglullis 6y agoFirst, creating value on top of the platform is not the same of extracting value from it. Second, the examples you give are not part of the core value of the companies. They are commoditizing their complements. [0] When Google releases a self-hosted version of their search and adwords programs, when Amazon makes AWS products compatible with OpenStack or when people can run iOS on any hardware and have access to the source, then I will start believing they are willing to give back proportionally to the amount of value they extract. [0]: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/
- sokoloff 6y agoDevelopers have made massive gains overall by commoditizing their complements. Linux OS is almost surely the largest single example of this. How many fewer developer jobs would there be now if every OS installation cost what Solaris used to cost (or even what Win2K8 Server cost)?
- rglullis 6y ago> Developers have made massive gains overall by commoditizing their complements Sorry, I am not following. What is the implication here, that application developersand Free Operating Systems are complemetary products? > How many fewer developer jobs would there be now if every OS installation cost what Solaris used to cost? Of course the market would be much smaller without FOSS, but how does this relate to what I am talking about? I wish we had more FOSS, not less. I wish people were willing to refuse the short-term apparent benefit/convenience of closed source and started at least hedging their investments on FOSS alternatives.
- sokoloff 6y ago> application developers and Free Operating Systems are complementary products Yes, that was my point (or at least application development and OSes are)
- 6y ago
- eru 6y agoI get a lot of value out of eg the Linux kernel. But I never contributed any value back to that project. What makes me a better person than Apple etc?
- rglullis 6y agoDo you use Linux to create applications that restrict user freedoms? If yes, then you are not better than any of them.