3 ms·
I used to be able to reliably distinguish 128kbps MP3s encoded with some mediocre encoder from the original audio (blinded, but I never tried double-blinded).
by amluto 6y ago
I used to be able to reliably distinguish 128kbps MP3s encoded with some mediocre encoder from the original audio (blinded, but I never tried double-blinded). I doubt I could pull off the same stunt with a top-of-the-line encoder, let alone with a better codec at an appropriate bit rate. A good codec can be made “transparent” such that no one call hear the difference except perhaps with deliberately chosen music that abuses that codec.
Now if only the world could settle on actually using good codecs...
- atoav 6y agoI agree. If you use OPUS for example, it becomes nearly impossible to tell. But one thing we should not forget: these codecs are used for distribution or streaming. If you ever record something that has to be edited, filtered, treated with an EQ, denoised etc. then go for at least 24 Bit Wav. Compressed audio is great for when the thing already sounds the way it should, but it starts to fall apart very quickly when you manipulate it heavily.