4 ms·
Bury it in the desert. Wear gloves. https://xkcd.com/2030/ https://xkcd.com/2030/
by wpietri 6y ago
Bury it in the desert. Wear gloves. https://xkcd.com/2030/ https://xkcd.com/2030/
- wpietri 6y agoAs an aside, XKCD #404 is my favorite: https://xkcd.com/403/ https://xkcd.com/403/ https://xkcd.com/404/ https://xkcd.com/404/ https://xkcd.com/405/ https://xkcd.com/405/
- overkalix 6y agoIt took me multiple F5s to get it...
- jimmaswell 6y agoShort sighted and needlessly defeatist in my opinion. Some people would've had us ride horses forever because the first cars were dangerous.
- wpietri 6y agoAs far as the computer security experts I've talked to, it's pretty much the consensus. Computers are very fragile, and have been my whole career. How many of us here make good money just keeping up with all the patches and fixes and defenses needed to make sure a modern system stays safe? Of course, some deep technological revolution might change that eventually. But in that case we still shouldn't rush to shift to a digital-only elections system. Why? Because it doesn't just have to work. Voters have to have confidence in the system. And that system isn't just technical, it's social. Everybody understands paper. Everybody understand marking paper. Everybody understands manually counting marks on paper and adding up numbers. Further, everybody has intuitions on how to protect and defend that process by making sure the right people are present. People do generally accept machine counting of paper ballots, because they don't see that as much different, and because they know a manual count can be done if there are problems. However technically clever and perfect some blockchain system is, it just doesn't have the simplicity and robustness in the face of attack or failure that we need. And it especially doesn't provide the social validation of what is essentially a social result.
- bigbubba 6y ago> Why? Because it doesn't just have to work. Voters have to have confidence in the system. And that system isn't just technical, it's social. I'd go even further and say that if voters believe in the system, it doesn't actually have to work. Belief in the system is the mechanism by which democracy provides stability. The election system actually working as advertised is only necessary to the extent that the system actually working is required to make people believe it works.
- jimmaswell 6y agoWe might not be ready right this instant but that's not a reason to not research the problem and make attempts to move forward. Something just seems wrong about sticking to paper forever. In my lifetime I should be able to vote from my phone in the middle of the ocean with satellite internet.
- wpietri 6y agoI understand you have a vaguely positive feeling toward the current signifiers of technical progress. But I have no idea why you think that weighs much compared with voter confidence in the democratic process that undergirds our society.
- jimmaswell 6y agoVoter confidence in technology can improve over time and progress has to happen. Like I said, I understand if it can't happen today, but it should be on the roadmap.
- wpietri 6y ago"Progress" does not in fact have to happen, and it's not at all clear to me that online voting constitutes progress.
- jimmaswell 6y ago
- benchaney 6y agoHard disagree. Blockchain gives a few very narrow security benefits in a specific situation. None of them are relevant for the purpose of election integrity. Some people are quite cavalier about switching over to computerized voting system despite not understanding the consequences. Resisting this trend is to the benefit of society.
- rs999gti 6y ago> Resisting this trend is to the benefit of society. Explain.
- benchaney 6y agoElections are important to society. Those elections being safe and secure is important to society. Computerized voting methods that are fundamentally unsound undermine that. They are occasionally being adopted anyway because of lobbying (read corruption). Voting against these officials, and informing society about the dangers of voting machines makes this type of corruption more difficult.
- rs999gti 6y agoYeah still don't get it. We depend on computers for things that can literally kill us, but not voting? Seems like the argument against computer voting leaves the door open for bad actors.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThis is less about "computers" and more about the adversarial nature of the process. Airplanes and elevators have computers in them but the "adversary" is gravity, which doesn't update its "attacks" to adapt to your countermeasures. Voting systems don't just have to defend their "planes" against high winds and lightning, they also have to defend them against surface to air missiles and rogue pilots.