3 ms·
This is on purpose. It's done to be as painful as possible while being legal to make the user hate the experience and blame the law, not the implementation. I'
by piva00 6y ago
This is on purpose. It's done to be as painful as possible while being legal to make the user hate the experience and blame the law, not the implementation.
I'm hoping the EU cracks down on dark pattern implementations, malicious compliance (as another comment mentioned) very likely goes against the spirit of the law. The ad-tech industry is quite powerful so I think this will drag on for a while.
While it drags out, I've been stubborn. Always refusing all cookies when I can't zap the cookie banner/blocker with uBlock. The most pain I can take is setting about 20 toggles. There are some implementations creating hundreds of lines of opt-outs, some where you have to opt-out vendor by vendor on their own website. Those are the ones where I close the page and forget about the content. It's not worth the hassle and my data.
I wasn't such an advocate for data privacy half a decade ago, I was aware about it and how it could be used, just had never seen it, not necessarily in action at the time, but being debated on corridors.
The unethical proposals I heard in meetings or by the coffee machines on how to extract/transform/identify through amassing data were quite alarming. Not because they were blatant bad but that the collective way of talking about it completely disregarded the end user.
GDPR really changed that talk internally, it's been a massive effort and a pain in the ass sometimes but I do value the spirit of it. Could it be the wrong approach? Or too heavy-handed? Misapplied? And so many other still unknown problems? Yes, I do think there are too much uncertainty in how this pans out on the long term. I do deeply appreciate the effort though from the EP and the EU in putting this into the public eye, we should have been having this discussion quite some years ago...
There are still tons of open questions and discussions to be had on data privacy laws, I feel the pain of having an increased workload because of it but it should become cost of business. Protection of your customers' data, its usage and their privacy should be a cost of business for companies depending on that. Level the game, create some mechanisms to help smaller companies be bootstrapped with this mindset and with guidelines and best practices for a quick ramp up.
It can be a cost of business for large enterprises, smaller companies might need help to not be overburden if these laws get too complex.
I don't think I'm too revolutionary.
- BlueTemplar 6y ago> There are some implementations creating hundreds of lines of opt-outs, some where you have to opt-out vendor by vendor on their own website. If I'm not mistaken, if there isn't a big 'Refuse All' (non critical) button on the 1rst dashboard 'page', then that implementation is considered to be illegal by the GDPR ?
- yeahforsureman 6y agoThe part of GDPR that gets applied here is the general standard for obtaining consent. It's very high-level stuff... So, without very specific case law, it's hard to say. The requirement that it should be as easy to revoke consent as it is to give one certainly resembles your argument.