4 ms·
This is a lovely illustration of the Curry-Howard-Lambek correspondence, but I fear that they'll still think of this as software because it can be executed. It
by Natsu 16y ago
This is a lovely illustration of the Curry-Howard-Lambek correspondence, but I fear that they'll still think of this as software because it can be executed. It might make the point stronger if one were to reduce it all the way back to typed Lambda calculus.
Though even http://us.metamath.org/index.html http://us.metamath.org/index.html itself seems to be unpersuasive, and it's concerned with writing the program equivalent to the ZFC axioms (which is, basically, the framework that underlies all the math most people have ever even heard of).
The person with the "what color are your bits" link, sadly, has the right idea. The law can, in fact, concern itself with distinguishing between mathematically equivalent things, legal fiction or not. It seems like we get more traction by arguing that the barrier to "invention" with software is so low and the risk of liability so high, even if one is not trying to infringe, that software patents hinder progress more than they help it.
Still, I love the illustration. Thanks for sharing.
- marshray 16y agoDefine your term "executed" as it applies to this Haskell source without using the words "transformation", "rewrite", or "evaluation". Probably you could do it somehow, but the point is that you're simply rewriting equivalent mathematical expressions as actual parameters are substituted in. If this program is patentable, then Gaussian elimination and everything in my high school algebra textbook is patentable.
- Natsu 16y agoI know it's truly equivalent and the differences between Haskell and math are illusory, I just think that it would be easier for non-technical people to go "oh, that's math!" if it was in the form of a calculus and if running it involved more than telling Haskell, "here's a Haskell source file, go for it." The point that one can, in fact, make an interpreter for mathematical statements is not lost on me. That's more or less what metamath.org is making, after all.