4 ms·
And once more literally no democrats count even a little bit as socialists. That notwithstanding it’s utterly disingenuous to equate social democrats with Madur
by arcticbull 6y ago
And once more literally no democrats count even a little bit as socialists. That notwithstanding it’s utterly disingenuous to equate social democrats with Maduro. The kind of “socialism” espoused by democrats is further right than substantially all of Europe, Canada, Australia and New Zealand. Far from failed, folks there enjoy a general higher standard of living than Americans.
- WalterBright 6y ago> literally no democrats count even a little bit as socialists 1. taxation takes the proceeds from the property - the higher the taxes, the more socialist. 2. Rent control. 3. California specifies the gender makeup of boards of directors. 4. Single payer health care. There are lots more, these are just examples. You can argue that the benefits of such abrogation makes it worthwhile, but they are socialism. The more of them, the more socialist. > Far from failed, folks there enjoy a general higher standard of living than Americans. The US then shouldn't be such a popular destination for immigrants looking for opportunity.
- arcticbull 6y agoWith reference to the definition of socialism: “any of various economic and political theories advocating collective or governmental ownership and administration of the means of production and distribution of goods” 1. taxation takes the proceeds from the property - the higher the taxes, the more socialist. Not a socialist issue, for instance Donald trump raised taxes by capping the SLPT deductions, and imo has nothing to do with the state owning the means of production. 2. Rent control. Not a federal or Democratic Party policy issue, just a stupid approach to control cost of living. The real answer is just supply and demand, and to permit building. This isn’t partisan it’s bad policy and has nothing to do with the means of production. 3. California specifies the gender makeup of boards of directors. That has nothing to do with the means of production and isn’t a federal issue. 4. Single payer health care. Not a left vs right issue IMO any more than a socialized fire department or police department are socialist. This is evident in the fact both democrats and republicans love Medicare which is literal socialized medicine for folks over 65. My personal opinion is that medical care does not fall under “means of production” and should instead fall under basic infrastructure which supports and facilitates the private ownership of the means of production. > The US then shouldn't be such a popular destination for immigrants looking for opportunity. This doesn’t prove or disprove anything. People often come to the US hoping they will do better than average. I suggested on average folks are better off elsewhere and your statement doesn’t prove or disprove that. Worse, immigration was basically wholesale suspended.
- WalterBright 6y ago> Not a socialist issue Trump doesn't define what socialism is or is not. Taxes are a taking of the proceeds of an enterprise, the more taken the more the owner is defacto the government. > Not a federal or Democratic Party policy issue It's local and state Democratic policy, and it certainly is socialistic. > That has nothing to do with the means of production Of course it is. It applies to business and how they are run. > Not a left vs right issue Of course it is. It comes from the left. > This doesn’t prove or disprove anything. Requiring them to all be wrong should perhaps give pause. Anyway, you're clearly focused on federal socialism. So I'll bring up Biden's plan to spend $2 trillion on all kinds of centrally planned economic initiatives, such as electric car chargers all over the place. The government has tried central planning of energy production and distribution before, back in the 70's. The DOE decided, for each and every gas station in America, how much gas it was allowed to sell. It was a disaster - gas lines and shortages everywhere. This all ended overnight with Reagan's first Executive Order. And I mean literally overnight the gas lines disappeared and never returned. I remember it well, it was wonderful not to have to plan for an hour wait for gas. The DOE proved simply incapable of putting gas where people needed it. Do you believe Biden's central economic planners will put the charging stations in the optimal place? I don't. But I suppose we'll see. In any case, it's still $2 trillion worth of socialism. > This is evident in the fact both democrats and republicans love Medicare which is literal socialized medicine for folks over 65. Of course Medicare is socialism. You are pushing the idea that Republican actions define socialism. I disagree - socialism is an economic system, and is not defined by who implements it.
- WalterBright 6y agoBy the way, I'd be a greener President than Biden. But I'd use market based solutions, as using a carrot is cheaper and more effective than the stick. For example, a carbon tax is a market based solution.
- arcticbull 6y agoI thought taxation was socialism :)