3 ms·
Data verification to predict drive failure seems like a decent use case though. The drive is always spinning, so you essentially gain an extra data path to do r
by XorNot 6y ago
Data verification to predict drive failure seems like a decent use case though. The drive is always spinning, so you essentially gain an extra data path to do read-verify-fix IOPs. Whether you can build this in cost-effectively is a big question though. But at rebuild times climbing to upwards of a week, being unable to do continuous health monitoring starts to get real problematic.
- rbanffy 6y agoThis would be cool, but it can be done with a single set of heads if the utilization is less than 100%. Multiple sets of heads would be useful if the limiting factor is positioning. BTW, I don't know how a multi platter drive records its disk blocks. Is a block contained in a single platter or does it spread across all platters and read/writes from all heads at the same time? Dual arms would be handy if the drive had a RAID-like checksumming scheme between platters. If a platter is corrupted but is still readable/writable (it wasn't a head malfunction), the drive could rebuild itself without the help of a computer. Even if it is a head malfunction, the data could be redistributed between the other platters, reducing the drive capacity.
- wtallis 6y agoThe specifics of how data is physically arranged across multiple platters is undocumented, complicated, and varies between models. But with some clever benchmarks, much of that information can be inferred: https://blog.stuffedcow.net/2019/09/hard-disk-geometry-microbenchmarking/ https://blog.stuffedcow.net/2019/09/hard-disk-geometry-micro... A hard drive will only use one head on one platter at a time. A single logical block will be contained within a single track on one platter. The next logical block will usually be on the same track or an adjacent track on the same platter. Seeking from one track to the next using the same head is generally a bit quicker than switching to a different head on a different platter and getting it lined up with a nearby track.