4 ms·
Class A architecture's main advantage is it is very easy to achieve high objective performance, while trading away heat and power (and consequently size and mas
by jeffbee 6y ago
Class A architecture's main advantage is it is very easy to achieve high objective performance, while trading away heat and power (and consequently size and mass). You can easily get 3rd harmonic below -80dB and you can eliminate even harmonics entirely. All you have to do it spend a lot on heat sinks and commit to a large power bill.
The problem is going to be reaching really stellar objective performance with the Class A design, because all those space age (not in a good way) power transistors are very slow and hard to drive, and that limits your error correction techniques. That's where these fancy designs are better. Basically they're using lightning-fast transistors and a DSP to bridge a power supply directly into a speaker. Objectively these designs have 3 orders of magnitude less total distortion, unmeasurable 2nd and 3rd harmonics, inaudible (-120dB or better) intermodulation products. The space age designs have simply no chance.
- willis936 6y agoBy slow do you mean high capacitance between base and emitter? I’m under the impression that even high power BJTs will be good out to 100 kHz. FETs are even better I believe. Adding more components to the signal path degrades the signal slightly at best and introduces additional non-linearities at worst.
- jeffbee 6y agoI think signal path degradation is thinking that can only be applied to linear amplifiers, and Class D amps are anything but linear. They literally short the power supply into the load with nanosecond timing. The transfer function through all that lossy, distorting stuff in the output path is pre-computed and equalized out by the DSP. If I had been more clear about what I was trying to say, I wouldn't have said slow and fast. What I was trying to emphasize was that the linear power amps are optimized around a linear ideal of a transistor that never existed. By contrast, the Class D amplifier exploits the characteristics of the transistors we actually make today: high dv/dt, high di/dt, Rds(on) close to zero. There are fifty companies out there trying to outdo each other on these stats and the closer they get to infinity/zero, the better the output of these new amps becomes. There are fewer people out there any more trying to make transistors more linear in the linear region.
- amluto 6y agoYou can always just use a big power op-amp. For some reason, audiophiles object to feedback, but any decent op-amp should give excellent audio performance. Power consumption and heat dissipation will be pretty bad, though. So you should go with class D.
- hatsunearu 6y agoI tried designing a modest amplifier using op amps for the majority of the frontend. It's basically impossible unless you add a lot of stuff to buffer the opamp (which is why I wanted to use an op amp instead of discrete stuff)... big power op amps that have decent distortion exists, but not at their rated power. You get like 0.1% thd at typical levels needed to drive an output stage. And also thermal distortion will absolutely be an issue at that point.