3 ms·
I think you and the article may be operating on different areas of the stack. You're talking about how to live your life with integrity. It's a matter of poli
by nostrademons 16y ago
I think you and the article may be operating on different areas of the stack. You're talking about how to live your life with integrity. It's a matter of policy, what should you do. The article is talking about if you do this, then people will react in this way. It's a matter of mechanism, how the world works. You can know the mechanics of how to win friends and influence people, but how you choose to use that knowledge is up to you.
It reminds me a bit of Machiavelli, which has since become a synonym for evil and dastardly deeds. But if you read The Prince, it's basically just a how-to manual for how to get and keep power. Machiavelli was writing for the Medicis, so it was assumed that they would want to stay in power. But questions about whether power was a good thing or not were out-of-scope for Machiavelli: he simply wrote about what one had to do if you wanted to gain power.
Also reminds me a bit of Feynman's views on technology and science, particularly the Manhattan Project. Feynman thought that technology was just a tool - it gives you the ability to do things you would otherwise be unable to, but it's up to you to decide whether you should do them. But wouldn't you rather have the ability to choose? It's the same with social hacks - you can do good things with them, you can do evil things, but at least you're aware of the effects of your actions.