3 ms·
States are not people, why should states have a voice? What voice would that be, if not the one of the people who live there?
by remram 6y ago
States are not people, why should states have a voice? What voice would that be, if not the one of the people who live there?
- beaner 6y agoStates having a voice is the whole point of a state. If states shouldn't have a voice, they should be phased out.
- rootusrootus 6y agoBut they do have a voice, they are an entire level of gov't. They shouldn't necessarily have any particular say in the election of the president.
- remram 6y agoStates "have a voice" in the local justice system and laws, as well as senators. Making the president of the whole country be elected directly by the whole country would not make states redundant, far from it.
- throwaway201103 6y agoBecause the constitution says the states elect the president. That's how it works. In modern times this means the people of each state decide, by popular vote, how their state votes.
- remram 6y agoYou're saying it should be like this because it is like this. That doesn't take us very far.