10 ms·
> The war on drugs was started as a way to target people of color by Nixon So was Planned Parenthood. Instead of endlessly prosecuting the past, which can nev
by zdragnar 6y ago
> The war on drugs was started as a way to target people of color by Nixon
So was Planned Parenthood.
Instead of endlessly prosecuting the past, which can never change, let's look at today and tomorrow instead.
Or, if you prefer, we could look at the exact opposite approach- the Opium wars were fought to force China to allow the sale and consumption of opium, the extensive use of which was practically epidemic.
As such, it could also be argued that legalizing drugs is an attack in minorities who are disproportionately poor and thus prone to consumption- a return to the days when inner cities were ravaged by crack.
Things are way more complex than just pointing at simplified versions of history and banging on the race drum.
- viraptor 6y ago> could also be argued that legalizing drugs is an attack in minorities who are disproportionately poor and thus prone to consumption Legalising the production and sale - yes, that would be possible. But legalising use and possession is very far from that. It opens the doors for better social approach to the problems and helps keep families together.
- dantheman 6y agoIf you legalize consumption but not production and sale - you make the black market thrive and basically sponsor organized crime. Full legalization is the only moral and practical approach.
- viraptor 6y agoThere's some threshold you probably don't want to legalise. With less addictive alternatives being available, do you really think that heroin production should ever be legalised? Otherwise what's to stop someone from creating a custom highly addictive drug purely for maximising profit? There are labs ready to do that. In Poland the drug laws targeted specific listed substances for a while which created a market for completely untested substances which were technically-not-drugs and the stock changed immediately after the drug list was updated.
- pessimizer 6y ago> do you really think that heroin production should ever be legalised? Yes. The actual cost of producing heroin is about a nickel a dose. Junkies who get their heroin are productive members of society, and aside from the criminal element they're forced to associate with, the crime they commit to get the cash to not get sick, the inconsistency of product, and the aggression of the state, we have no reason to think they wouldn't live long happy lives other than ideological ones. Every junkie death is by statute.
- viraptor 6y agoWhy concentrate on ongoing use rather than providing addiction treatment?
- jowsie 6y agoYou're a lot less likely to relapse and commit crime when you're already on a stable dose of your drug of choice. Considering how many people in america are on legitimate opiod prescriptions I find it insane how people instantly jump to 'well you wouldn't legalise heroin would you?!', there's no meaningful difference between opiods whether they're prescribed or not.
- jessaustin 6y agoWhy concentrate on anything? Heroin addicts who desire treatment will be welcome to it, but others will choose otherwise.
- Jochim 6y agoOne argument would be that taxes from the sale could be used to fund better addiction treatment than is currently available. State sanctioned supply would then be taking money out of the hands of organised crime and using it to help the people who need it.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> you make the black market thrive and basically sponsor organized crime You aren't "Making" a market, it exists already. The difference is we are no longer severely punishing the people who are getting victimized. > Full legalization is the only moral and practical approach. Full legalization for most drugs, I agree (weed, LSD, shrooms, plus a few others). But I'm not sure I'd agree that all drugs should be legalized. A measured approach as we have done with MJ is a good idea.
- pessimizer 6y ago> The difference is we are no longer severely punishing the people who are getting victimized. No, the difference is that we are no longer victimizing the people who are doing drugs.
- pstuart 6y ago> So was Planned Parenthood. No it wasn't: https://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2015/08/14/432080520/fact-check-was-planned-parenthood-started-to-control-the-black-population https://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2015/08/14/43208...
- zdragnar 6y agoEven planned parenthood has been disavowing her: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/21/nyregion/planned-parenthood-margaret-sanger-eugenics.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/21/nyregion/planned-parentho... In her speech the morality of birth control, she openly advocated for preventing undesirables (todays' deplorables) from procreating. Edit: NPR's cherry-picking nice sounding quotes doesn't describe the totality of the woman, her views or the organization- then, or now.
- pstuart 6y agoBut to frame it as the reason the organization was created is fallacious.
- pjc50 6y agoPlanned Parenthood was the work of Margaret Sanger, who was a feminist who believed in reproductive choice and free speech; she was repeatedly arrested because distributing knowledge of contraception violated the Comstock Act.
- cptnapalm 6y agoMargret Sanger was a eugenicist.
- pjc50 6y agoThis is unfortunately true. Does not imply that the current organization is, though.
- zdragnar 6y agoThat was entirely my original point- that the war on drugs may have been started with ill intent 50 years ago should not have bearing on today's policy decisions. Whether we legalize or not, whether that helps minorities or not, i think we agree that constantly recriminating the past isn't helping.
- pessimizer 6y ago> i think we agree that constantly recriminating the past isn't helping. We don't. You're advocating for both actively ignoring the reasons that we did things, and for the assumption that things that we do are done for a reason.
- mythrwy 6y agoThe relative percentages of babies aborted by race might though. (disclaimer: pro-choice)
- eznzt 6y agoEugenics may currently be immoral, but they are scientifically sound. (I know this comment is off-topic, but so was his)
- pessimizer 6y agoI don't understand your point. The war on drugs started for a single function, and operated to accomplish that function consistently during its entire history, and currently accomplishes that function. Planned Parenthood also helps poor people have access to family planning. Sanger started it with exactly that purpose in mind. That now it helps educated people have access to family planning also is a nice expansion of its original purpose. That Sanger's purpose in encouraging family planning in the poor was to eradicate them is as relevant as Nixon's love for Notre Dame football. > Things are way more complex than just pointing at simplified versions of history and banging on the race drum. You haven't given any evidence of that. You're encouraging to ignore our lying eyes and our entire history and replace them with your bitterness about the discussion of race.
- mythrwy 6y ago"The war on drugs started for a single function" Really? China's banning of Opium was because of racism? There were real concerns about drugs (and alcohol see: prohibition). That is the main reason it happened. Disenfranchising minorities and hippies was likely only a side benefit for unscrupulous people.
- imgabe 6y agoThis may be US-centric but when people talk about The War on Drugs™ they mean specifically the US campaign against drugs and the ensuing police-state. Yes, other countries at other times have also made drugs illegal, but the war on drugs refers to the US policy specifically.
- mythrwy 6y agoRight I got that. My point is many nations ban drugs. In fact they pretty much all do at some level. Meaning there are other reasons besides racism and thus that is likely not the primary reason like this silly "Nixon" comment I see on every post about drugs.
- 6y ago
- post_below 6y agoI think understanding the past, especially the truer version that tends to become available years later, is extremely important. Personally I appreciate when people point out what really happened (based on evidence) as a counterpoint to the cover narratives of the time, which so many still believe. We need cynicism where politics and public institutions are concerned.