3 ms·
N=1 is a shorthand. It means it’s a science experiment with a sample of one. You. In the even older times, we used to say, “Your mileage may vary.” https://ww
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
N=1 is a shorthand. It means it’s a science experiment with a sample of one. You.
In the even older times, we used to say, “Your mileage may vary.”
https://www.ketogenicforums.com/t/in-case-anyone-else-wondered-what-n-1-means/32103 https://www.ketogenicforums.com/t/in-case-anyone-else-wonder...
It's not actually an accurate description of my situation because my two adult sons still live with me and one of them has the same diagnosis I have and the other is a carrier. So N=2 or N=3, depending on how you wish to count that.
While I agree with the gist of some of your points, I always cringe when people leave the kinds of comments you have left here, starting with "Don't worry about not being a doctor - that's a good thing!" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25014092 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25014092
My statement that I'm not a doctor is a statement of fact. It's not an apology. It's not an expression of low self esteem.
I have participated on HN for more than 11 years because the standards for discourse of scientific information here are high and that fact has helped literally save my life, which has made it worth my while to put up with drama swirling around me for a long list of reasons.
Over the years, I've been fortunate to have some folks with PhDs in various fields (including chemistry and biology) answer some of my questions and explain some critical details in layman's terms to help me better understand cell function, among other things. Some of those folks were met via HN.
My gut reaction to people acting like I have self esteem problems and need my ego massaged because the HN crowd is capable of dishing out criticism just makes me go "Please stop helping me" which is an old TV Tropes entry that has since been disambiguated into two separate categories:
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/StopHelpingMe https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/StopHelpingMe
- feralimal 6y agoI'm glad you agree with the gist of my points. I also absolutely understand that you would cringe at my comments. Whatever, I may say though, is no reflection on you. If you were to meet me in person I don't think you would cringe if we were to talk. But on a forum, you only have a short amount of time to make an impression, catch people's attention, and try to get them to consider what I think is truth. People are so indoctrinated, they can barely recognise it. Here, on HN, there are many people who love science - it is their religion. They don't think its a religion, but it is - they believe in it, they don't know it. They don't even know what knowing is. The accept the pronouncements from the priest-scientists, as if they were gospel. A cursory review of some science study is all it takes. But the point of science is that it should be verifiable, not based on belief. No one is verifying anything, and when studies are peer reviewed 70% cannot be replicated. 70%!! In fact, I love science done properly too, but that is nowhere to be found. I hold to application of the scientific method personally. In all areas of my life. If I have any ambitions in my interactions on HN, it is that I wish for others to engage their rational thinking, not just when tackling a gnarly coding issue, but also in other parts of their lives. I wish that people would think more individually, rather than just going along with the herd, what they have been taught, etc. Questions people should be asking include: Why is it so medicine so expensive? Has the 'health' system been captured? When was it captured? Why don't we know what the right food for humans is? Why were we taught the food pyramid? Is food medicine? Is pregnancy an issue that requires medical intervention? Etc. If you really start to find answers to those questions, the reality of this existence takes on an entirely different perspective. I appreciate that you are looking into this stuff for yourself. I appreciate that you are sharing your understanding and anecdotal results. I'm glad that you clarified that it is not n=1 but n=2 or 3. Given what I understand about science, I genuinely value the anecdotal points you raise highly. I have gained much more useful information anecdotally than from 'science'. Finally, I would say, that along with fasting, I understand that the Gerson method is excellent more providing you with nutrition and along your body the space to repair itself. And in repairing itself, I understand there will be a healing crisis, where the build up of toxins etc may be expelled and that that can mean that one feels worse than ever. But that this is an essential step on the path to wellness. All the best.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoBut on a forum, you only have a short amount of time to make an impression, catch people's attention, and try to get them to consider what I think is truth. I've been here more than eleven years. I don't think it works that way at all on HN. Best.
- feralimal 6y agoI'll try to post an update here in 11 years! I may well have changed my mind! :)
- Retric 6y ago> The accept the pronouncements from the priest-scientists, as if they were gospel. That’s really not how scientists think about science. The respect is for the body of evidence not the interpretation of that evidence. The way the coastlines of South American line up with Africa isn’t some words from on high, you can see it for yourself. People still get wigged out by relativity let alone quantum mechanics weirdness while acknowledging how useful those models are. The innate feelings that models are wrong rather than data isn’t religious any more than a babies understanding that dropped balls fall. Even before language develops people internalize the idea of cause and effect being linked. That’s the only assumption made by science everything else is observation and math. As such observation can always beat any theory no matter how old. It’s simply accepted that the most well known and perhaps most useful scientific law “F=MA” is wrong. No breakaway groups holding up such a sacred tenet, just a quiet understanding that nope that’s not quite how the universe works.