5 ms·
Expected, I suppose. But it's still surreal to me that I'd need rows of full rack servers I used to install 25 years ago just to equal the core count here. Man
by tyingq 6y ago
Expected, I suppose. But it's still surreal to me that I'd need rows of full rack servers I used to install 25 years ago just to equal the core count here. Many, many, more rows to get anywhere near the capability.
I suppose it's more surreal than comparisons I made back then because there's very little difference, really, in the operating system and popular languages.
- ta988 6y agoI replaced 4 servers (doing computation work not serving things so no need for availability) at work with a single desktop computer with a ryzen 7... Between the sata vs nvme the RAM speed and the CPU speed, tasks finish faster on rhe Zen2... Oh and it is 1/8 of the power as well. My only problem is that I can't get WoL to reliably work, only the mode that wakes up with any packet works.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stepbeek 6y agoI’ve found from building a few Ryder machines now that while the CPU itself is amazing, the eco-system around it remains less polished than intel. Hopefully this changes with Zen 3 looking like an awesome consumer chip.
- rq1 6y agoThey “just” miniaturised the rack into a chip :)
- db48x 6y agoOr at any rate into the chassis; all those PCIe lanes have to go to devices that are mounted somewhere.
- anon73044 6y agoWe have disk shelves now, wouldn't the next step be a "network shelf"? And probably a "GPU compute" shelf later on with some kind of high-speed high bandwidth backbone tying them all together. Turn the whole rack into a glorified backplane. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ sounds like something IBM would do.
- fulafel 6y agoWe've had pretty high parallelism in server CPUs for a while, eg Ultrasparc T1 had 32 threads in 2005, later generations with 128 threads (T5). But a high number of threads and cores is a worse solution than being able to keep up high single threaded execution speedups, as most programs are not multithreaded because parallel programming is so hard.
- mnd999 6y agoIt’s not though in the server space. Many server workloads are inherently parallel because the support multiple concurrent users. Think database servers or web servers.
- fulafel 6y agoThe speed is strictly worse as no application works better in this scenario, and most are worse (latency).
- tpxl 6y ago>strictly worse I'm pretty sure double the core count at 90% of the speed will get you better performance in _a lot_ of scenarios.
- fulafel 6y agoBy sustaining single core speedups, I meant big speedups, like we were observing bin the days before mainstream CPUs resorted to multiore. It was rather more than 10%. And we'd still have be able to make processors with lots of slow threads of course for applications where that's cost or power effective, that's comparatively very easy.
- tpxl 6y agoYes, having one core at 2x clock is definitely better than having two cores at 1x clock, I'd agree with that. These days however, the difference between fastest core performance on low-core processors and fastest core performance on high-core processors is rather a lot less than 50% (Comparing like for like, eg AMD to AMD and Intel to Intel).
- fabian2k 6y agoI'm curious if they will keep up the increase in core counts. It might get more difficult to do that unless the new TSMC processes work very well. They probably would have to go to 16 core (2x 8 core CCX) chiplets as I don't think they can easily fit more chiplets into Epyc.
- barbacoa 6y agoI imagine some day soon they will start stacking core dies like they do for memory.
- accountofme 6y agoI imagine they will need to get quite creative with the cooling process to pull that off.... I have heard of in die water cooling, but that sounds like the only option.
- chiph 6y agoSales of 3M Flourinert are sure to go up. (famously used in the Cray 2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluorinert https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluorinert
- kllrnohj 6y agoZen3 is still TSMC 7nm. So expect identical core counts & cache sizes as the existing models, but each core is ~15-20% faster Similarly expect similar prices since nothing there really changed either. Yields are a very known quantity at this point.
- ksec 6y agoWell you can expect 128 Core from 5nm or 3nm. I would guess 3nm makes more sense from a die size perspective. I imagine Zen 4 on 5nm would be the same as Zen 3 except with 16 Core and the same amount of cache, since the L3 Cache are now shared. But the problem isn't so much with the Core Count but the TDP per Core. Imagine it is 3W per Core, 128 Core gets to 384W. And that is excluding the IOD.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoMy surreal moment was reading the Genetic Programming series by John Koza. He discussed a 1000 socket Pentium II cluster which was used for a genetic search. I did some back of the napkin math and realized that was roughly equivalent to my Zen 2 box. So of course my failure to replicate the author's success was not the fault of my hardware.
- qz2 6y agoSimilar situation here. Circa 2000 I had a few separate machines in my lab making lots of noise, taking up lots of space and drinking up power. Now I run a much larger cluster of nodes on my zen 2 desktop in virtual machines. If I need some more I rent them from amazon for a few hours rather than having to go and buy something expensive.
- raverbashing 6y agoHah interesting. I remember a John Koza book but that was before the PII era I think. Also he liked Lisp (so maybe that's why he needed all that computing) In the end it seems GA/GP was an "overoptimizing" for very non-convex/non-linear search spaces (much more than real problems) and that we're better off with NN/SGD representations of problems
- reitzensteinm 6y agoThere was a whole series of them, GP I-IV. I believe it was GP II that was discussing the Pentium II cluster. I have had a lot of fun this year building a neural network from scratch as well as genetic programming. For real tasks, it does seem that the former has won out. I have a layman's suspicion that GP will find itself useful in some way and have a resurgence in the future, but it might just be naïve wishful thinking.
- walrus01 6y agoThis makes me think of Slashdot jokes from 20 years ago about 'imagine a beowulf cluster of these'. I once worked for a server manufacturer that did a setup with hundreds of 1U size, dual socket Pentium 3, 1.0 GHz CPUs. In the era when the only way to have more than one core was a dual socket motherboard.
- gravypod 6y agoI recently had one of these realizations when looking at https://research.google.com/archive/mapreduce-osdi04-slides/index-auto-0006.html https://research.google.com/archive/mapreduce-osdi04-slides/...