7 ms·
As mentioned above, it may not be appropriate for everyone, particularly those who are underweight or very ill I have an incurable, serious condition. In recen
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
As mentioned above, it may not be appropriate for everyone, particularly those who are underweight or very ill
I have an incurable, serious condition. In recent years, I'm fairly regularly too broke to eat adequately. As a consequence, I fast or semi-fast part of most months.
I've slowly gotten healthier. Fasting or semi-fasting is not the only reason by any stretch of the imagination.
Anecdotally, it's gotten easier as I've gotten healthier.
I read once (or heard from someone) that if you cut calories by 80 percent -- a figure not shown in their chart defining their terms -- it triggers the "starvation" response. Your body thinks you are starving, much as if you weren't eating at all.
I have found that semi-fasting -- eating maybe 20 percent of normal calories -- has fasting-like benefits for my condition while being much, much easier to endure as someone with a real serious and incurable medical condition.
This is absolutely not medical advice of any sort for anyone. I am not a doctor. I'm a person with a chronic illness running my mouth on the internet.
- ganafagol 6y agoAnd maybe you would have gotten even better without this forced fasting. Now you may consider me heartless for this response, and that would be sad because I really feel for you man. But this is why anecdotical evidence, especially first-hand from people affected, does not hold much ground in the scientific method. In other words, my comment provides neither less nor more evidence than your comment does.
- feralimal 6y agoI couldn't disagree more. With science so utterly serving corporate interests, the only information that has a possibility of being true, IMO, is anecdotal evidence. This person is applying the scientific method personally, and cautiously. And he is sharing his experience with you. Whereas science only pays lip service to the scientific method. Its only there to make money. If you are interested in what I'm saying, you want to look into how science is as I say, take a look at the following: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_Most_Published_Research_Findings_Are_False https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_Most_Published_Research_Fi...
- jiggunjer 6y agoThere are so many flaws in your reasoning I don't even know where to begin. I guess ignorance really is bliss.
- angrais 6y agoThis is quite disheartening to read. We do know that the OP did NOT apply the scientific method - just look at the estimated timeframes. Estimates are not science. Likewise, N=1 and sharing experience is not "science", particularly for public health issues. I'm not going to waste my own time arguing why you're wrong, but a TDLR is you are and frankly it's a shame to read. As an aside, you're correct in that reporting of research methods could be improved and there are issues of replication, but this is for many reasons. One of the less reported issues is money - that's not how research funding works. You're claiming science is flawed, then link to wiki - is that a joke? Are you a researcher?
- feralimal 6y agoThanks for NOT taking the time to explain to me how I'm wrong. I just am wrong, right? So says the voice of science! (I couldn't have asked for a better example of how science pays lip service to the scientific method only!) I link to wiki, not because I think it is authoritative, far from it. Like the NYT, CNN, Guardian or BBC which deliver us our daily propaganda messages, wikipedia delivers us the historical narrative we are meant to accept. When they themselves say 70% science studies are unreproducible (ie lies) you know that we're in a world of BS! Science is busted, but I find that individuals are able to relay the truth more fairly and accurately.
- Retric 6y agoScience is the testing of ideas. The reason N=1 isn’t science is there is no way to isolate what’s going on. If nothing else time is a factor which is always increasing for such cases and may represent the bodies ability to heal over time. The classic advice of take two Aspirin and call me in the morning is really equivalent to just wait a day, and you could substitute pray for an hour before bed. So, “shockingly”, if the advice is pray for an hour before bed it’s going to seemingly work for most things especially if told to repeat it and just pray harder. Except, again they could have said sing the national anthem before bed and that’s also effective as is doing most non strenuous activities. This is generally true if what’s being suggested has other effects achievable in other ways. If losing weight is beneficial then fasting will seem really helpful though other options for weight loss exist, those where not tested because again N=1.
- beagle3 6y agoExcept the person you are replying to has a very long history, on HN (under this and an older account), and long blog history which are very informative. This specific comment, like any other single one, isn’t much. But her whole body of documentation, anecdotal as it is, is actually extremely useful.
- ganafagol 6y agoThanks for providing some context. Informative history is great. And the part where she mentions that she ought to get a nobel prize makes me cautious with overall interpretation of said context, since that tends to be a counterindicator. Gives some confirmation of the point i was trying to make though.
- monktastic1 6y agoFYI, "Doreen" is generally a woman's name.
- akeck 6y agoIt's awesome that you figured this out even though the circumstances aren't great. I hope your health keeps improving.
- feralimal 6y agoDon't worry about not being a doctor - that's a good thing! Doctors would NOT advise anyone to cut calories by 80% even if, as in your case, it improves your health. Nor would they advise a diabetic to abstain from carbs, and so take away the trigger for their condition. (Ie - you don't have diabetes if you don't eat carbs.) 99.9% of doctors will only prescribe drugs. The medical industry is not about well - its about maximising illness for profit. And improving diet and eating behaviour is the last thing they will do - there's no money in that!
- Dayshine 6y ago> Nor would they advise a diabetic to abstain from carbs, and so take away the trigger for their condition. (Ie - you don't have diabetes if you don't eat carbs.) 99.9% of doctors will only prescribe drugs They don't right now, because the evidence around the long-term effects isn't sufficient. They're clearly coming round to it though. See the section "Dietary advice" in NICE guidance. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng17/resources/2019-surveillance-of-diabetes-nice-guidelines-ng17-ng18-ng19-and-ng28-6837997933/chapter/Overview-of-2019-surveillance-methods?tab=evidence https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng17/resources/2019-surveil...
- DoreenMichele 6y agoAnyone at risk of diabetes or dealing with diabetes should also look at research into the relationship between diabetes and inflammation, which suggests that there may be other factors to consider beyond just diet for how to best prevent and mitigate the condition. There is also interesting research into how protein (muscle health) impacts insulin resistance: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8748147 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8748147
- hirako2000 6y agoThank you for posting your thoughts on the business centric approach of our modern medical system. It makes me feel less crazy sìnce nobody I talk to face to face about even want to hear it. "Our doctors are working hard towards our own good"
- lmilcin 6y agoIntermittent fasting gets easier with time for many different reasons. Your body learns to differentiate hunger from the feeling of not being sated. You learn to exercise willpower which is good not just for fasting but in general. Your body trains metabolic pathways that are normally dormant or active for a very short time of day. Your body learns to recognize and switch metabolism faster, causing lesser and shorter "hangover" effect. I am on/off intermittent fasting (ie. sometimes stop, mainly due to social demands), but I noticed it became easier to start intermittent fasting.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoWhen you are too broke to buy food, will power has nothing to do with it. In my case, when I say it has "gotten easier," I mean that, for example, it takes a much longer time and a much more significant restriction on calories to provoke vomiting. There is a long history of me vomiting in reaction to doing things that are beneficial to my condition. Some years ago, I used to throw up all day about three days out of the month for up to sixteen hours. The last time fasting caused significant vomiting for me was around December 31st of last year. It was after two days of more extreme circumstances than usual in terms of being underfed and was on the heels of a longer period of having trouble getting enough to eat. It was incredibly miserable and took a month to recover from, but as is typical for such incidents it also permanently improved my baseline functioning. Years ago, I asked around and was able to determine that part of what I vomit up is likely bile. I end up bringing up a great deal of foul-tasting fluid. I sometimes throw up after lunch and sometimes my lunch stays down. It is common for me to only vomit foul fluids. (Edit: What I mean is that sometimes immediately after eating, I throw up foul fluids and the food I just ate stays down.) The incident at the end of last December did not involve foul fluids. Instead, I threw up large quantities of thick gunk. It was torture and if I wasn't absolutely certain that this was going to resolve soon and would lead to me being permanently improved because of it, I would have done my damnedest to kill myself that day because it was just so awful. When I was too exhausted to stand up any longer and too dehydrated to keep throwing up, etc. I ran a bath. Laying in the bath helped take the edge off my misery enough for me to fall asleep for a while in the bath. Since then, I mostly don't throw up in reaction to being underfed for just a day. I used to routinely throw up at lunch time on semi-fasting days, which means after maybe half a day of mostly not eating. It now tends to take two days or longer before vomiting commences.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Anecdotally, it's gotten easier as I've gotten healthier. Hunger is a weird thing in how it affects different people. I've done the "master cleanse" without really being bothered, while my significant other can barely last half a day without needing something to eat. Being as how she's one of the toughest (and fit) people I know, it can't be chalked up to willpower.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoMy condition significantly interferes with the way my body metabolizes dietary fats. This causes most people with it to be deficient in all fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K) and to typically have far too little body fat. Ironically, although I have shrunk as my edema has improved, I probably have more subcutaneous fat, making it possible to go into ketogenesis. I probably had no (or too little) fat reserves to draw upon previously, making fasting particularly hard on me.
- tarsinge 6y agoIt's also very variable on the individual level and you have to know your body. For example if I eat even a little in the morning it's impossible for me to fast and I'll be hungry mad by midday. But if I only drink coffee and have a lot of work to do the day can pass smoothly without feeling hungry. Also dependent on the type of food for me, food dense in proteins and fats can feed me for the day, while with carbs I'll be hungry a few hours after.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoI think you are referring to "fast-mimicking diet", or FMD. Prof. Valter Longo is considered to be one of the pioneers of this particular field if studies. [0] [0]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6816332/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6816332/
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThank you for that link: A post hoc analysis of subjects from both FMD arms showed that body mass index, blood pressure, fasting glucose, IGF-1, triglycerides, total and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, and C-reactive protein were more beneficially affected in participants at risk for disease than in subjects who were not at risk.