3 ms·
Freedom of contract. FREEDOM!! Americans have every right to sign horrible contracts. They can also done all thier money to doll museums, or gamble it away i
by sandworm101 6y ago
Freedom of contract. FREEDOM!!
Americans have every right to sign horrible contracts. They can also done all thier money to doll museums, or gamble it away in vegas. Like it or not, any measures that sound like they are limiting consumer choice, even choice to make obvious mistakes, will face serious resistance.
The outer limits on contracts are things like slavery, children, and taking advantage of the disabled. Bad printer service contracts dont come close.
- a1369209993 6y agoThat is specifically the problem here; you don't have freedom of contract if there is no possiblity of negotiating a different contract.
- sandworm101 6y agoThe freedom is before signing. You are free to sign or not, make whatever deal you care to. That includes signing away your ability to get out of bad deals.
- a1369209993 6y ago> You are free to [...] make whatever deal you care to. Again, the problem is specifically that you are not free to make whatever deal you care to, because the counterparty has been permitted to amortize the costs of adversarially designing one particular deal across a large number victims, and consequently is able to refuse to negotiate.
- CobrastanJorji 6y agoI'm a big proponent of freedom to do dumb things, but in general when MOST people freely choose any given dumb thing, that's a strong symptom that they are not freely choosing.
- corty 6y agoI like the German approach here (surprise, /me German...): Non-negiotiable standard contracts that are applied to consumer contracts en masse are called "Allgemeine Geschaeftsbedingungen (AGB)" (roughly: common business conditions). A business may apply those, but if they do, they need to conform to a restrictive law (AGBG) regulating what is and isn't allowed in such conditions. E.g. no future changes without an exchange of equal value to the changes, no surprising clauses that are not "normal" for this kind of situation, no grossly unequal considerations to begin with. Individuals and businesses still have freedom of contract however, if a contract is really negotiated freely, that is, in an equal exchange between both parties. If there was no negotiation or a very unequal one ("take it or leave it, we'll block any of your change requests but you need the ink now"), AGBG applies. In all situations mentioned above, the consumer had no opportunity to negotiate (a symbolic "negotiation phone number" in the smallprint doesn't count, etc), so all those fancyful clauses or the whole contract conditions would just be unenforcable, with the most consumer-friendly interpretation applied to the rest as a matter of law.
- tripzilch 6y ago> Americans have every right to sign horrible contracts. Sure, if you want to be known as Land of Horrible Contracts .. populated by people slavishly abiding by them in a state of learned helplessness. If you call that "freedom", I truly hope that someone will take it from you.