16 ms·
> It appears that the people who argue that roguelike means something different now have never (or almost never) played a roguelike in traditional sense. It al
by kibwen 6y ago
> It appears that the people who argue that roguelike means something different now have never (or almost never) played a roguelike in traditional sense.
It almost seems like the author is begging for refutation, but I'll bite: I have multiple allrune victories in DCSS (and have also contributed code to the game) and have been around roguelike communities since the mid-2000s (so before Spelunky, FTL, etc), and I have no issue with the modern use of the word "roguelike". In fact, I'm delighted! I think the "run-based" machinery that can be traced back to Rogue (with all the trappings that tends to imply: tangible loss upon death, random layouts, etc.) have been one of the best trends in gaming of the past decade.
It's similar to what happened to RPGs. Remember what "RPG" used to mean in the 90s? Then remember when games starting incorporating "RPG elements" (e.g. character progression through leveling and experience points) into other genres? Turns out there were some widely-applicable, generally good ideas that had mostly only surfaced themselves in classic RPGs that took years to gradually diffuse into the medium at large. So goes the roguelike.
- username90 6y ago> Remember what "RPG" used to mean in the 90s? It meant the same as now. We do have sub genres like "Action RPG" or "with RPG elements", we don't call any game with RPG elements RPG's. So instead of calling any game with permadeath "roguelike" why not just say it has permadeath? Would cause less confusion.
- Normal_gaussian 6y agoThese categories are all tags anyway, trying to build a distinctive taxonomy of games is futile. Most sensible philosphers have long since abandoned categorical absolutism and there are many hundreds of years of arguments around it. Call them tags and the generality of the tag becomes irrelevant. If enough people like some combination or derivation of rogue elements then roguelike is good enough. The issue with non specific tags (roguelike vs permadeath) is that the membership defines it, leading to either infinite dilution or periodic membership - think the evolution of political parties.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]