8 ms·
> Crucially, the mDL application can ask the user to approve which data to release and may require the user to authenticate with fingerprint or face — none of w
by kelnos 6y ago
> Crucially, the mDL application can ask the user to approve which data to release and may require the user to authenticate with fingerprint or face — none of which a passive plastic card could ever do.
I kinda feel like most people, when threatened by an authority figure with a gun, will approve whatever data that person asks for.
The place where I do think this is valuable is when showing ID to get into a bar, or at a store when purchasing alcohol. The only bit of info the bouncer/cashier needs is whether or not you are of legal drinking age; they don't need to know your actual age/birthday or your name or address.
- gruez 6y ago>I kinda feel like most people, when threatened by an authority figure with a gun, will approve whatever data that person asks for. It's not supposed to be a foolproof solution. The point is to prevent the officer from casually looking through your photos/texts after you gave him the phone.
- freeone3000 6y agoThe solution to that is a plastic card that has none of that info.
- ianferrel 6y agoA pretty common way to get a fake id is to borrow a real id from someone else. Bouncers ask you how old you are or what your house number is as a check on that. That seems like a plausibly useful feature, or are there other ways to tell that the virtual id matches the real person holding the phone?
- kelnos 6y agoIs this common, though? In my 18 years of legally entering bars, that has literally never happened to me, even when I was in my early 20s.
- casefields 6y agoEarly 2000s they used to. Out here in LA, and in Vegas too. Those are the only places I've gone out with any regularity. Nowadays it's seems they just trust the scanner.
- ianferrel 6y agoI don't know how common it is. It does happen, though. It probably depends a lot on the bouncer's impression of how old you likely are and how much you look like your license photo. I changed hairstyles dramatically between my license photo and age 21, so I had my license challenged a significant (probably single-digit percentages) number of times until I got a new photo in my mid-20s.
- mawise 6y agoUntil the bouncer (or the bar's contracted developer) thinks it's easier or more secure to use the "Request all data" feature, and logs everything to an unprotected MySQL database. When a bouncer looks at your ID he doesn't write down or save any of that information. This really seems like a solution looking for a problem.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoYes they do, bouncers now scan the IDs they look at with a machine.
- kelnos 6y agoAs a sibling mentioned, they already have ID barcode scanners in many bars, and then sell your data to marketing companies. I think I'd be fine walking away from a bar that used this system to request everything, rather than just a simple "over 21?" verification question. There are plenty of bars out there and I don't have to patronize shitty ones.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- diebeforei485 6y agoThe barcode at the back of a physical license card has all sorts of information that may not be printed at the front. For example, for noncitizens in the US it can have some information about visa status. If there is a standard (name, DOB, photo, address, height, weight) that's probably more than enough.
- lurchpop 6y agoBut it will be bar policy to have your name/address/email info or their reader won’t authenticate you.
- kelnos 6y agoI'm perfectly happy not patronizing those establishments. With the current system, I could easily believe that not all bars scan the barcode for a nefarious reason, but do it just to make it easier to avoid a bad manual reading (different ID layouts per state, darkness making it hard to read, etc.). With this kind of digital ID, requesting anything more than my age and photo is an immediate flag to me that they're explicitly looking to do something shady (or at least they're incompetent and don't know how to use the reader properly). I would deny everything but the age and photo request, and if they balk, I'd ask to speak to a manager or just walk away.
- Zanni 6y agoAs ID to get into a bar, I think minimally they'd need access to your photo too, to ensure you haven't just borrowed (or bought) a phone.
- kelnos 6y agoFair, but that's fine and reasonable, I think. If I'm entering their establishment they're well within their rights to have cameras inside that can take my photo, so giving them access to my ID photo doesn't sound like a big deal to me.