3 ms·
> My strong belief is that programming languages research does not value usability because there currently is no satisfying, agreed-upon way of evaluating it.
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> My strong belief is that programming languages research does not value usability because there currently is no satisfying, agreed-upon way of evaluating it.
This is talking about usability of the programming language - or of a language that incorporates whatever conclusions the research reaches. This matches something I've been thinking a lot lately, that software engineering is a different animal than computer science. If your PL advance is the greatest CS thing since sliced bread, but it isn't usable for actual programmers working to write programs, then... who cares?
The ergonomics of computer languages is not what computer scientists think it is. CS types complain about how stupid the field is to use languages that don't reflect the best CS research. The reality is, the CS researchers are too ignorant to grasp what actually makes languages useful in the field.
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoThe author of this post is a computer scientist, who is explicitly talking about adding these measures of usability to experimental evaluations to PL papers
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoSure. I'm talking about the bulk of the CS PL field as a whole, and I don't think I'm disagreeing with the author of the post. (Do note, however, that the author left academia and is now in the field...)
- giantDinosaur 6y agoCS Research : Programming, Physics : Engineering ? I think you can level this criticism, and yeah, you have a point, but I think there has to be constant back and forth between the practitioners and those who develop theory or else both sides seriously lose out.
- benjaminjosephw 6y agoStrongly stated but I think there's some truth here. Most serious programming languages have a bias towards concepts explored in the academic study of programming languages. Of course academic theories sometimes provide a great foundation with some pretty solid ideas but they needn't be the only source of good ideas. Programming is a design exercise and figuring out how to help humans think and explore design is something I think practitioners have more to say on than theorists. Or at least if not more to say, they certainly have more of a contribution to make in this space than we've seen so far. (disclaimer: I'm a practitioner without a CS degree working on a programming language)