4 ms·
There actually isn't unequivocal evidence of war in the early archaeological record, although that is more to do with the definition of "war" than "humans were
by jcranmer 6y ago
There actually isn't unequivocal evidence of war in the early archaeological record, although that is more to do with the definition of "war" than "humans were inherently peaceful."
A plausible modern definition of war is that it is a conflict between two polities that sanctions otherwise illegitimate violence by particular people. That is, war is undertaken by government (not individuals); it requires the use of special participants (military forces); it requires a definitive, positive interaction to commence (e.g., a declaration of war); and it has rules that need to be observed. The exact contours of the definition will differ from author to author, and there are plenty of conflicts that sit in a nebulous gray area (would The Troubles constitute a war? or the Colombian conflict between the government and FARC? or gang wars?), but broadly speaking, you will see some sort of line being drawn between warfare and mere violence.
Archaeology tells us that there is pretty clear physical evidence of mass violent deaths as early as the Mesolithic. However, cultural evidence of warfare is not easily established: cave paintings in the Paleolithic don't depict anything like warfare, and even in the Mesolithic, evidence for warfare in paintings is kind of thin. It's really not until the development of sedentary agriculture in the early Neolithic that we see clear evidence of warfare, and even here, the evidence can easily be interpreted in a way that suggests it wasn't a major feature before then.
- jgilias 6y agoThank you for writing this! Her reasoning wasn't this deep though. It went mostly along the lines of idillic prehistoric humans solving every issue with mating until patriarchy driven civilizations came along and messed up the world.
- Shorel 6y agoIf we compare ourselves to other primates both chimpanzees and gorillas show deadly violence with a relatively high frequency. Even bonobos are quite vicious when they are not fucking. Meaning all high status males have probably killed at least one member of their species in their lifetime. Orangutans are the odd elevated ones.