7 ms·
Wow, this is actually much worse than I thought it would be from the title! > HP rolled out a pay-on-price "Free Ink for Life" plan that gave you 15 pages ever
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
Wow, this is actually much worse than I thought it would be from the title!
> HP rolled out a pay-on-price "Free Ink for Life" plan that gave you 15 pages every month for as long as you owned your printer. But this is HP we're talking about, so words have no meaning. Last month, HP notified its "free ink for life" customers that their life had ended, and they were being moved to a new afterlife where they had to pay $0.99/month
And from what I can tell in a quick Google search, HP introduced the "free ink for life" plan less than a year ago. So "life" lasted less than a year!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pishpash 6y agoThis has definitely been available for more than a year, but no more than about ten, from my memory. Edit: Looks like it started in 2013, under Meg Whitman. [1] Also, this user says it was ad-sponsored! [2] [1] https://www.therecycler.com/posts/hp-launches-new-instant-ink-programme/ https://www.therecycler.com/posts/hp-launches-new-instant-in... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/printers/comments/874mi2/question_ads_in_hp_instant_ink_free_plan/ https://www.reddit.com/r/printers/comments/874mi2/question_a...
- bserge 6y agoInteresting, I've only heard about it ~3 years ago when I got a cheap (and reliable, fwiw) Envy AIO, but it was not free.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThank you! I couldn't get an exact date, and made a hasty assumption because I couldn't find any stories about the program that predated January 2020. (But I didn't search for too long.) It doesn't look like the "free" plan was available all the way back in 2013 though—it's not mentioned in your first link, and they presumably would have brought up something like that. And more importantly, they were clearly still using this plan to sell new printers as recently as this past winter...
- smsm42 6y agoThat looks like a class action suit. I can't believe "free X for life" can be reasonably interpreted as "free X for a year and then you have to pay".
- Bjartr 6y agoAs if there wasn't a binding arbitration clause in the Ink for Life service agreement.
- jnsie 6y agoI always wonder if it is reasonable to assume that people are capable of understanding service agreements. Like, could a court make a decision that the customer was not a lawyer and therefore could not fully understand the agreement. Further, that the barrier to hiring a lawyer to understand such an agreement is too high (i.e. expensive) and it is unreasonable to expect the customer to do so.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CobrastanJorji 6y agoA court COULD make that decision, but there're centuries of precedent that this is not the case, which is tragic. The court will assume that no reasonable person would agree to a contract without reading the contents and consulting with a lawyer on anything that is unclear during the contract's negotiations, and for major contracts between large companies, they would be correct. It would be a nearly revolutionary change to introduce a law like "you cannot meaningfully agree to any contracts or agreements without a lawyer advising you and a representative of the other party empowered to negotiate the terms." I'm all for it, though. You'd need to fix several other kinds of laws around liability for negligence and the like, but those things need fixing anyway. The current hack where everybody agrees to waive their rights to sue for negligence is stupid. You would, however, need a new kind of thing that handled common agreements like terms of a credit card. There need to be terms, hiring lawyers for each person is ridiculous, but "contract" is probably the wrong model since no customer could be expected to understand it all, meaningfully consent to it, or negotiate the terms. I would be interested in what an alternative system could be. I kind of imagine a government body deciding on acceptable terms for various forms of business, effectively acting as the customer's agent in negotiations, but that seems ripe for corruption and also really inefficient and hard to innovate around. Suggestions?
- bserge 6y agoReally shouldn't be surprised by the shit HP pulls... At least their workstations are still great.
- nine_k 6y agoI imagine a robber growling "$0.99 or your life!" It's hard to tell what is more insulting, the ending of a "for life" program or the amount because of which it ends. Also, another big warning against stuff which is "free" or "for life"; in most cases, either is commercially unsustainable.
- nogabebop23 6y ago>> or the amount because of which it ends. a buck to print 15 pages a month on the customer's printer is a sweet deal for HP. It's pure profit and likely adds up. 6 months from now they'll bump it to $1.29 and some executive will get a multi-million dollar bonus.
- jandrese 6y agoA typical inkjet cartridge prints around 190 pages. So at 15 pages per $1 this is like buying cartridges at $13 a piece, except way more complicated and obnoxious. Cartridges normally cost around $20 so it is still a slight savings if you're willing to deal with the hassle of counting your pages every month. For me however, I give that whole plan a giant middle finger. That's way too much headache and hassle for a $7 savings.
- tinus_hn 6y agoBut only if you print exactly 15 pages each month
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThey do roll over up to 45 pages, so it's not entirely unreasonable that someone would use all or at least most of their credits.
- dm319 6y agoWhile that is awful, I think the 'free ink for life' plan was just as sneaky in itself. Having bought a cheap HP inkjet printer recently, I was curious about the free ink plan. But it's a trick - you can't agree to the free ink, then just buy 3rd party ink when you want more. No, if you go over 15 pages a month, the IOT printer will automatically order you the ink and bill your account. Buying cheaper ink will just be a waste of ink because you won't be able to print with it without ordering more HP ink. That is truly evil.
- time0ut 6y agoIt has definitely been around for more than a year. We bought a printer three years ago that tried to get us to sign up for this. I remember it being pretty aggressive about it too.
- atoav 6y agoI had a HP printer once. That was enough for me to learn that I will never buy any product from them ever again. These kind of "we need to trick money out of you" methods are not limited to their printers. The one HP notebook that I installed half a decade ago was the worst bloated system I have ever seen. Only their displays seem to be not cursed by that plague — yet. It is too sad that there is no reasonable open hardware printer, so for now brother laserprinters will have to do. Costs <100€, toner cost per page is low and the thing runs for a decade (in my case) without weird issues.