4 ms·
According to the law, this is incorrect. A technological measure to control access is effective if, "in the normal course of its operation" (that is, when it is
by bitwize 6y ago
According to the law, this is incorrect. A technological measure to control access is effective if, "in the normal course of its operation" (that is, when it is not being bypassed), it protects the rights of the copyright owner to some piece of work. The most trivial thing -- JavaScript code that disables right clicks -- can be effective under this standard. And getting around it would still be a crime.
- Buttons840 6y agoWhat if I distribute youtube-dl behind some trvially bypassed JavaScript protections and some passwords and "you're not authorised" messages a la CFAA, then have an "enemy" spread knowledge of how to bypass all this on some shady forums? Who sues me? And how many felonies do they commit in building their case against me? In other words, there's a catch-22 in how strict we are about the definition of effective protection. 99% of the public won't even open their browser tools so I guess if youtube-dl is put behind some very generously documented JavaScript that is easily bypassed then it is not actually out in public because it is effectively DRM protected, right?
- croes 6y agoThe javascript example shows the problem of this definition. What if I have disabled javascript or use a browser without javascript? I wouldn't even know that some kind of protection exists.