8 ms·
Honestly I lost all respect for Ma when I watched him debate Elon on the topic of AI last April [1]. Elon just ran circles around him. Like, Elon was playing ch
by arcticbull 6y ago
Honestly I lost all respect for Ma when I watched him debate Elon on the topic of AI last April [1]. Elon just ran circles around him. Like, Elon was playing chess and Ma was playing hopscotch with a football helmet and padded gloves.
That video gave me a lot of insight into Ma's character, and frankly, the contents of the article were thoroughly unsurprising in that context.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSKYWu-S2G0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSKYWu-S2G0
- threatofrain 6y agoIt's extremely difficult to say that Jack Ma is an idiot because of his discussion with Elon Musk. Jack Ma has to play a parallel game of high-stakes political poker.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoAnd do it in a non native language. In Germany my friends spoke very good English, but there were still times they'd sound like the drunken ramblings of a native speaker. Only later on I'd realize the points they were trying to make and that they were running rings around me intellectually, just having trouble expressing it. That experience has left me more or less giving a free pass to ESL speakers saying things that sound dumb, especially when it's off the cuff.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt’s what he was saying — not how, in particular the part where he believed machines were incapable of being smarter than humans, because if you try to compete with them in an area they’re good at you’re dumb for doing that. He then contradicted himself by using the example of a human in a foot race with a car. Then he states that human intelligence comes from the soul anyways. To be fair, Jack Ma was an English teacher, has a Bachelor of Arts in English from Hangzhou Teachers University and he was an English lecturer at Hangzhou Dianzi University. While he may have an accent his communication style is quite clear IMO. If I thought this was at all a language or communication issue I’d never have posted it.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoWell he sounds to me like he was struggling. Very much so. If I didn't think he was, I wouldn't have posted what I did either. I agree the points he was making were vapid, and I stopped watching fairly quickly because of it. Maybe he really is an idiot, but I don't think this video was at all conclusive proof.
- yorwba 6y ago> It’s what he was saying — not how You also need to take into account to whom he was saying it. Although they were ostensibly talking to each other, Musk was speaking to the fears of Americans afraid their jobs might get automated, while Ma was addressing Chinese who hope their jobs will get automated. Consequently, their definition of "smart" is not the same. Musk equates smartness with being good at your job, while Ma thinks it's better to be "street smart" and let someone else do the work for you. Or in the car vs. human example, why try to outrun it if you could be sitting in the driver's seat? > Then he states that human intelligence comes from the soul anyways. I thought that was a clever riff on Musk's somewhat awkward "AI means love in Chinese, right?" conversation starter. > To be fair, Jack Ma was an English teacher, has a Bachelor of Arts in English from Hangzhou Teachers University and he was an English lecturer at Hangzhou Dianzi University. While he may have an accent his communication style is quite clear IMO. I don't know whether you've ever experienced a foreign-language class taught by a non-native speaker, but I've taken Academic Writing classes in English at a top Chinese university and the quality was terrible. English literacy is rare in China even though it is a mandatory subject, so the bar to becoming a teacher is quite low. Often, they'll have an excellent breadth of vocabulary, while being unfamiliar with many idiomatic expressions and cultural references that come naturally to a native speaker. That said, I did think he was communicating quite clearly, but since my understanding appears to be quite different from yours, maybe that's just a reflection of our different expectations. On the other hand, if the event was specifically organized so that they could speak past each other and endear themselves to their respective audiences, it was a genius move.
- Danieru 6y ago> "AI means love in Chinese, right?" conversation starter. Oh neat, a pun which works both in Japanese and Chinese.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ciarannolan 6y agoJack Ma taught English at the university level [1]. He wasn't struggling for words, he's just not as smart as some had assumed. [1] https://money.cnn.com/2018/09/09/technology/business/jack-ma-alibaba-bio/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2018/09/09/technology/business/jack-ma...
- reitzensteinm 6y agoAs a sibling reply pointed out, this doesn't necessarily mean as much as you think it means.
- ciarannolan 6y agoCan you link it please? I'm not seeing it.
- reitzensteinm 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25006975 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25006975 For what it's worth this matches my own limited experience from the early 2000s.
- ciarannolan 6y agoThanks! Relevant from other comment: > I don't know whether you've ever experienced a foreign-language class taught by a non-native speaker, but I've taken Academic Writing classes in English at a top Chinese university and the quality was terrible. English literacy is rare in China even though it is a mandatory subject, so the bar to becoming a teacher is quite low. Often, they'll have an excellent breadth of vocabulary, while being unfamiliar with many idiomatic expressions and cultural references that come naturally to a native speaker.
- programmertote 6y ago100% this. As a English-as-a-second-language speaker, there are times when I wish I could speak up and express my thoughts/emotions in a way that is palatable to the audience (native English speakers), but decided to stay quiet because I am not sure if it'll come out right or because my brain cannot process fast enough to speak fluently/eloquently. I consider myself fairly decent in English vocabulary and reading (not bragging but scored 720 out of 800 in both SAT and GRE verbal), but I still cannot do as well as native speakers in expressing my concerns/opinions during business meetings. Sometimes, I wish the tables are turned so that I can speak my native language and am able to make persuasive arguments in discussions. Language barrier is real and I am guessing some English speakers may never understand/empathize with the non-native speakers.
- not_a_moth 6y agoGiven that Jack Ma has been a member of the CCP since the 80s [1] I think his success has come a lot easier than Western entrepreneurs [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/11/27/alibabas-jack-ma-has-been-communist-party-member-since-1980s.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/11/27/alibabas-jack-ma-has-been-co...
- dragonelite 6y agoDoes it really matters, i mean US industrial/tech giants all donate to the parties to get some advantage nationally and globally? Should we be questioning western CEO political affiliations and donations when talking about their companies?
- indigochill 6y ago> Should we be questioning western CEO political affiliations and donations when talking about their companies? Absolutely. Political affiliations speak to the philosophy of the CEO and, by proxy, how they'll lead their company. E.g. Palantir is behaving exactly as expected given Peter Thiel's politics.
- manigandham 6y agoWhat's that actually mean? Does he even have a choice to not be a member? What are the chances this is rewritten history for PR?
- dmix 6y agoI read in a book about China by New Yorker magazines China expert [1] and he said that up to a third of Chinese citizens are either party members, part of youth groups, or work directly for a CCP owned company. So it’s not everyone but it’s a lot. The actual CCP membership itself is much lower though. It’s more like an octopus in their society. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Age-Ambition-Chasing-Fortune-Truth/dp/0374535272/ https://www.amazon.com/Age-Ambition-Chasing-Fortune-Truth/dp...
- 6y ago
- malux85 6y agoJack Ma is an idiot, and he’s just surrounded himself with a bunch of yes men, who can buffer the operational, legal, financial systems that run his empire and mostly protect him ... but his true nature comes out when he’s required to engage in 1:1 discussion with anyone great. At that point there’s no filter directly to his consciousness and it’s clear, from that video, that’s he’s a total moron.
- baybal2 6y agoI knew some people who worked in Alibaba at around the time when Ma started to handing over duties to Tsai, and Zhang. All say the company was actually much better run when Ma was managing company day to day, than when after Tsai took over operations, and himself just hired tons of "pro managers" to hand over errands. At around this time (2012-2013), Tsai decided to show how much of a serious tech exec he was..., and he came with idea to do what big boy do, and rewrite all of Alibaba's core code into one True Enterprise Grade Java MegaFramework of Doom. And it was at that time when their website quality started to fall off a cliff, and they started loosing talented people who were off-put by Tsai's management... I'd say Aliexpress was much better at the time of it launch, than it is now. Alibaba, and 1688 had an even more dramatic loss of quality, and vendor oversight. P.S. People talk about party affiliation of Ma from him joining the part to be allowed to teach in eighties, while forgetting that Tsai does not even hide his affiliation with the United Front (an organisation for CPC's version of "useful idiots,)" and is a much more outspoken political player, and party appologist.
- projektfu 6y agoI’ve never really understood how one can use Alibaba effectively. It’s mostly spam from middlemen who lie about having their own factories. It must be a full time, specialized job being a purchasing manager who can use the platform.
- baybal2 6y agoThe thing is, their search used to be much better, and they had much better spam control before.
- scotty79 6y agoI wonder how different would the conversation feel if it was done in chinese not english.
- ddorian43 6y agoHe can do it with Zuckerberg. Pretty sure the result would be the same.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoI think that’s underselling Ma, who was an English teacher, graduated with an English degree and was an English lecturer at university.
- blackbear_ 6y agoThis is interesting because I felt the exact opposite, seeing Musk babbling incoherent ideas and Ma with a clear vision of AI's future.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Darmody 6y agoI remember watching some of his stuff and thinking, the guy knows his stuff. But then I started watching more and it didn't make sense. He sounds more like some kind of new age guru or a motivational speaker rather than someone with a good insight into the future. He's probably in the position he is because he bows down to the CCP.
- arcticbull 6y agoMy thoughts exactly. Bowed down -- and then got too big for his britches maybe, and forgot who was actually in charge.
- Darmody 6y agoWell, maybe being under an oppressive regime makes him look dumber than he really is. If you can't say certain things and have the obligation to say others...you could end up making no sense.
- approxim8ion 6y agoI feel the same about most pundits and billionaire "visionaries" touted today, to be honest. Including Elon.
- comboy 6y agoI remember this one and I’m pretty certain he is not that stupid. Must have been political pressure. Maybe AI is/was taboo.
- tpmx 6y agoAI isn't/wasn't taboo there - the opposite, rather. https://becominghuman.ai/china-aims-to-be-a-leader-in-ai-by-2030-ec5382329034 https://becominghuman.ai/china-aims-to-be-a-leader-in-ai-by-...
- TenJack 6y agoI wonder if he just doesn't have a good enough grasp of the English language to articulate his ideas well enough. I would go as far to say that no self-made billionaire is stupid.
- arcticbull 6y ago> I would go as far to say that no self-made billionaire is stupid. Making money is far more about luck than skill. Always has been. Net worth is not a proxy for ability. [edit] Don't get me wrong I'm not saying billionaires are idiots. I'm just saying that having a fat stack is not in and of itself a proxy for aptitude. Judge that on the person instead. Just judging them on their bank balance is an unnecessary appeal to authority that hasn't historically held.
- manigandham 6y agoThat may be the case for millionaires in the right place at the right time but not for the self-made billionaires.
- Pungsnigel 6y agoI'd say normally it requires both, or extreme levels of either. Not sure normal rules apply under CCP though.
- dlkf 6y agoI'll raise you to extreme levels of both.
- cambalache 6y agoNot necessarily.You need to be smart, but not in the sense HN thinks.A charismatic, charming person can become quite wealthy if luck and connections help and still be very dumb by conventional standards. People like Kim Kardashian.
- WanderPanda 6y agoI would still argue net worth is a unbiased (if you discount for corruption) proxy for ability (in the sense of ability to create wealth = products and services that people demand). It is extremely high variance though
- manigandham 6y agoCan Ma even speak freely? I find it hard to judge a conversation when one of them is under incredible political pressure by a powerful regime that has no problem squashing him at any time.
- cambalache 6y agoSure, but to be honest Elon Musk is neither a person worth listening regarding AI.
- hungryhobo 6y agoAgreed
- ffpip 6y agoThe first comment made me laugh. ''He's not stupid. He just has a lot of Alibaba Intelligence.'' Jack Ma had said AI is Alibaba Intelligence
- knolax 6y agoSums up the HN mentality to me. "some foreign business exec didn't correctly decipher a cryptic technical abbreviation that only exists in my language correctly? What an idiot".
- franklampard 6y agoHe is also a proponent of 996. Zero respect
- dredmorbius 6y agoFor those unaware: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/15/business/jack-ma-996-china/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/15/business/jack-ma-996-china/in...
- fossuser 6y agoSame for me - after seeing that I became convinced he's just some figurehead the CCP put there in what's ultimately a government funded/run business. I wasn't surprised when they removed him.