4 ms·
Show HN: My 1-week project, OpenCombinator.com
Anyone can be a mentor or investor in some walk of life. Anyone can be a founder, creator or student in another. Anyone can mod their own, or someone else's news list.
A tool without restrictions, operating on a finite set of rules. You decide whether it evolves to be used for good or evil.
- noduerme 16y agoAnyone can be a mentor or investor in some walk of life. Anyone can be a founder, creator or student in another. Anyone can mod their own, or someone else's news list. A tool without restrictions, operating on a finite set of rules. You decide whether it evolves to be used for good or evil.
- bdickason 16y agoI don't understand what an upvoting news site has to do with advisors or entrepeneurs. How does the right column relate to the left? I understand that Ycombinator has hacker news, but the two aren't tied to each other very closely.
- noduerme 16y agoYC is great, but it's essentially closed to other investors and, while the program is merit-based, it's a closed selection process. HN is nice because there's a meritocracy at work; the concept is to allow that type of meritocracy to force both investors and entrepreneurs to have to work for one another's attention. The site is just a conduit for BPs or proposals from the most motivated idea-people to get into the hands of the most motivated action-people in any area. And every area can be broken into two parties with a mutual interest in industry news, who need to sift through each other to find the best people on the opposite team to work with. So; this is just an engine based on that concept, with up/down votes serving as an objective determinant every month.
- duck 16y agoI read everything on the page, but have no idea what it means.
- vyrotek 16y agoI've poked around and even created a SubCombinator. But, I'm still trying to figure out exactly what the site offers. In some aspects its feels like Hacker News with Reddit sort of categories. Then you have this Expert/Student system. Honestly, I'm not completely sure I understand it. I see that I can set myself as the expert for a SubReddit...I mean SubCombinator. "At the end of every month, the top five Sensei (advisers or investors) in each area will receive the proposals of the top ten Grasshoppers (entrepreneurs or activists), based on points earned for intelligent posts and comments that month." So, this didn't make sense to me until I registered. If I understand correctly, you 'pre-fill' a sort of pitch/proposal that you want to be sent out. Then based on your activity in the site it will be emailed to the 'Experts' of the SubCombinators where you've earned the most points recently. Does that sound right?
- noduerme 16y agoRight. You fill in your proposal, which is kept hidden. If you're in the top 10-rated "grasshoppers" in a subcom, at the end of the month, your proposal gets packaged into a nice email that goes out to just the top 5-rated "sensei" or experts.
- vyrotek 16y agoHave you shared this with people who would be experts and actually interested in receiving proposals? I guess I don't fully understand how my activity in a news sharing site makes me important to an investor. You're basically trying to reward people who participate and submit links with the idea that their pitch will be seen by an investor who is following a topic you contribute to. Its definitely an interesting approach. And there's some work to be done on the UI, education and flow within the site. You just need to make sure there's real value for everyone involved.
- noduerme 16y agoI have, and there are a few investors who are waiting to see what happens here. Myself included. It's got to be an organic process; hopefully some people with great ideas will start posting and sharing their concepts, and it will snowball. Although I should stress I don't see this as a primarily IT-oriented site, it could become anything, or go in any direction, depending on who gets involved. In a lot of ways it's an experimental, theoretical model. I have no idea if it will really work, but I can imagine a lot of interesting proposals being collected that would be interesting opportunities for investors, who in turn will have to work to get their ratings up, in order to see those proposals.
- calebmpeterson 16y agoInteresting idea but to be honest, the color palette is quite distracting - there's too much going on. * the yellow background for the news items is a show stopper - the text will look just fine on it's own! * the two-tone peach/cream background for the main content blocks is distracting. instead try a subtle tone for the left section and the page body color for the news section * the dark grey background + blue headers and footers is not cohesive. make the background a very light grey or creme color (#f8f8f8 for example) and if you want the headers and footers to have a color, I'd make them extend the full width of the page or else make them flat (no-gradient) Of course, this is all my opinion, and you get what you pay for right? :) Good luck with this interesting idea!
- noduerme 16y agoThanks. I pro'lly gotta work on that. I get a little carried away once I start CSS'ing.
- calebmpeterson 16y agoSure thing! It's about iterating a piece of work and revising.
- proexploit 16y agoCool project, I played around with the CSS a little bit myself but didn't have as much time a I thought (running late right now) but I'll still show you what I came up with so far just so you can see an alternate perspective. Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/U4uO8.png http://i.imgur.com/U4uO8.png Color Scheme: http://i.imgur.com/6oUyx.png http://i.imgur.com/6oUyx.png If you like it and actually want to implement it, shoot me an email (proexploit[at]gmail.com) and I'll clean up the CSS and send it to you, this was all done in firebug and turned out messier than I intended.
- calebmpeterson 16y agoThat looks quite nice.
- 16y ago
- brackin 16y agoDon't use terminology like Sensei and Grasshopper as it confused me with what the idea even is. Plus it means you've got a lot more text with all the brackets. Although I do not like the colour scheme, it's really distracting.
- ZackOfAllTrades 16y agoMake it pretty. I cannot think when I see that page.
- ajhai 16y agoFor the design part, go through this ( http://paulstamatiou.com/startup-web-design-ux-crash-course http://paulstamatiou.com/startup-web-design-ux-crash-course ) post by Paul if you haven't already. That really is a crash course in design and should help you get started.
- jarin 16y agoAfter that, http://www.blueprintcss.org/ http://www.blueprintcss.org/ (or http://960.gs/ http://960.gs/) and http://www.colourlovers.com/palettes http://www.colourlovers.com/palettes
- acgourley 16y agoAdvertising that you only spent one week on it hardly makes me want to invest my own time in it. It sounds like a website thats going to rot away in the same timeframe.
- galuggus 16y agoWhat the fuck was that about? I'm so sorry to speak so frankly but I thought this time my unvarnished first impression would be useful The overwhelming screaming in my head was What the fuck was that about? Make it clear what you are trying to achieve. fewer distractions. one goal Good luck
- rgbrgb 16y agoHere's my take on on the design (which should be priority #1 if you think the idea is any good): Minimize the number of font styles. I'm counting over 10 distinct size/face/color/decoration combinations. Cutting that down to 3 or so will reduce the ugly tremendously. Also try to figure out what you want users to read first, next, etc and figure out a structure where that feels more natural. At the moment, I'm totally confused when I look at it. I'd also try to come up with a more concise description of what the site does. After reading the description on the left, I'm still kind of confused.
- noduerme 16y agoOkay. CSS and color scheme need to be improved. Definitely need to think of how to explain the message more clearly. Nicer graphics, easier-to-read fonts. Check. What does everyone think of the idea of a user-controlled, up-ranking newsgroup where the highest rated investors receive the proposals from the highest rated entrepreneurs? I know the site isn't beautiful. It's a concept. I just wanted to get the bare bones framework in place and launch it... Of course I want it to be pretty, but I'm more concerned about whether the idea can hold water. I spent a week on it because that's how long it took to write the code; the "graphics" took about an hour. I want to test the function before I spend time beautifying. I want to know if this idealistic model actually pans out and rewards the investors who take the time to rank on it. Specifically, at the end of the month, I want to see the quality of the proposals that go to investors and whether we get any interesting startups funded out of it. Hopefully in green tech, non-profits/NGOs, etc, as that's where I'd really like to see this go.