5 ms·
"DMCA 1201 says that it's illegal to bypass a digital lock in order to access or modify a copyrighted work." No, 1201 says, among other things, that it is a vi
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
"DMCA 1201 says that it's illegal to bypass a digital lock in order to access or modify a copyrighted work."
No, 1201 says, among other things, that it is a violation of the Copyright Act (which may only carry civil liability, so not necessarily "illegal") to share the means to circumvent access controls to a copyrighted work. That is the part of 1201 the RIAA cited in its letter.
It is the sharing that is the alleged 1201 violation. Not any circumvention.
- jimktrains2 6y agoI'm curious how this interacts wit the First Amendment, especially if the circumvention itself is legal.
- shmerl 6y agoIt is unconstitutional. EFF filed a court case to repeal it. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/06/first-amendment-case-against-restrictive-copyright-law-can-proceed-says-judge https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/06/first-amendment-case-a...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago2 out of the 3 First Amendment claims (overbreadth, prior restraint) were dismissed. The one that survived was that 1201 might be unconsitutional as applied to the specific set of facts: a researcher publishing a book on encryption. The case is ongoing; there are no indications that EFF will succeed.
- shmerl 6y agoSomeone should succeed, may be legislators who shouldn't have allowed this to exist in the first place. Corrupt DMCA 1201 garbage should be eventually repealed.
- zucker42 6y agoI certainly believe it's unconstitutional but as an non-expert I think the courts feel skeptical of that argument (I believe they argue circumvention is conduct and not speech), and are perhaps less likely to review such cases because they feel it's unimportant. I'm hopeful about the EFF litigation though.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> No, 1201 says, among other things, that it is a violation of the Copyright Act (which may only carry civil liability, so not necessarily "illegal") Illegal (“contrary to or forbidden by law”) , but not necessarily criminal.
- bitwize 6y agoWrong. Section 1201 (a) (1) (A) says: "No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title. The prohibition contained in the preceding sentence shall take effect at the end of the 2-year period beginning on the date of the enactment of this chapter." So circumvention itself is also illegal under the DMCA. But this issue is about trafficking in circumvention devices.
- croes 6y agoIf you can circumvent the technological measure it isn't effectively controlling access, is it?
- briandear 6y agoThat’s like suggesting a locked door that gets picked isn’t really breaking and entering.
- emayljames 6y agoBut the "lock" in this case doesn't exist.
- bitwize 6y agoIt's more like saying owning lockpicking tools automatically makes you a thief. (Which is the law in some states, like Illinois).
- croes 6y agoI doubt the laws against breaking in talk about effectivly locking the door. It's just entering without permission.
- feanaro 6y agoMore importantly, if a work is distributed under a "protection" mechanism that is regularly bypassed by browsers, does that mean that browsers are circumvention tools too?
- zucker42 6y ago> No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201
- emayljames 6y agoKey word that makes the claim fall apart is effective. If the RIAA where to win, then it would mean just opening a URL would give the site owner grounds to file proceedings. An example being a DB being left open to the internet, that has sensitive data, the DB owner would be able to file a case if you just opened the DB.
- Buttons840 6y agoAnd when defining "effective" we should not only consider YouTube, but also the software protecting that one guy's personal collection of over 9000 movies that he has exposed to the web for his own personal use. For example, if YouTube has effective DRM. Then I suppose I should be good to throw up all the latest Disney movies on my personal website, for personal viewing, behind that same effective DRM, right?
- Arch-TK 6y agoThe "technological measure" doesn't "effectively" control anything. You can circumvent it using the inspect element feature of any modern browser. yt-dl "cirucmvents" it by executing the javascript (the same thing your web browser does). At this rate V8 is going to get DMCAd for the same reason.
- Rizz 6y agoEffectively of course means "in effect" in this context, for example YouTube doesn't have to prove the measure was designed to limit access, only that it does in some way. Pretending yt-dl simply does what YouTube does is obviously not true either, because if it did, then yt-dl wouldn't exist. The copyright holder decided he would allow the streaming of the work, if you want to download it you should either get the ok from the copyright holder for that or choose another work to download, or even make one yourself. V8 doesn't change that.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoThe RIAA letter cites 1201(a)(2) and 1201(b)(1). The letter alleges sharing of circumvention software. The letter does not cite 1201(a)(1); it does not allege circumvention. For a section 1201 violation to be criminal it needs to be willful and for the purpose of financial gain. See Section 1204. To me, the term "illegal" means "in violation of the law", and hence enforceable by so-called law enforcement. Here, non-wilful violations of "the law" that are not committed for financial gain are only enforceable by copyright owners. This, to me, falls into the category of violating someone's intellectual property rights, not violating "the law". If you see things another way, that's fine. I respect your opinion and ask that you in turn respect mine.
- qiqitori 6y agoHere's the full text of the relevant sections, from https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201. (Though who knows, there might be other relevant stuff somewhere.) Note the use of the phrases "primarily designed", "has only limited commercially significant purpose", "is marketed ... for use in circumventing" -- I think the RIAA is on thin ice in this respect, but that's not for me to decide of course. Grepping through my bash history I see some stuff that could perhaps be RIAA stuff, and other things that aren't. Anyway: (a) Violations Regarding Circumvention of Technological Measures.— (2) No person shall manufacture, import, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof, that— (A) is primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title; (B) has only limited commercially significant purpose or use other than to circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title; or (C) is marketed by that person or another acting in concert with that person with that person’s knowledge for use in circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title. (3) As used in this subsection— (A) to “circumvent a technological measure” means to descramble a scrambled work, to decrypt an encrypted work, or otherwise to avoid, bypass, remove, deactivate, or impair a technological measure, without the authority of the copyright owner; and (B) a technological measure “effectively controls access to a work” if the measure, in the ordinary course of its operation, requires the application of information, or a process or a treatment, with the authority of the copyright owner, to gain access to the work. (b) Additional Violations.— (1) No person shall manufacture, import, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof, that— (A) is primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing protection afforded by a technological measure that effectively protects a right of a copyright owner under this title in a work or a portion thereof; (B) has only limited commercially significant purpose or use other than to circumvent protection afforded by a technological measure that effectively protects a right of a copyright owner under this title in a work or a portion thereof; or (C) is marketed by that person or another acting in concert with that person with that person’s knowledge for use in circumventing protection afforded by a technological measure that effectively protects a right of a copyright owner under this title in a work or a portion thereof. (2) As used in this subsection— (A) to “circumvent protection afforded by a technological measure” means avoiding, bypassing, removing, deactivating, or otherwise impairing a technological measure; and (B) a technological measure “effectively protects a right of a copyright owner under this title” if the measure, in the ordinary course of its operation, prevents, restricts, or otherwise limits the exercise of a right of a copyright owner under this title.
- ur-whale 6y agoArguing the finer points of a law that is deeply flawed in the first place strikes me as a terrible waste of one's intellectual talents unless the goal is to get said law to be revoked.