4 ms·
It's definitely strange; normal DMCA requests are to remove infringing content, but youtube-dl is code, not content.
by musicale 6y ago
It's definitely strange; normal DMCA requests are to remove infringing content, but youtube-dl is code, not content.
- brokenmachine 6y agoI believe some of the tests download a very small amount of copyrighted content.
- shakna 6y agoExactly 10Kb of the video. Which would very likely fall under fair use.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThis still isn't relevant for a DMCA takedown request, youtube-dl was not hosting the content.
- brokenmachine 6y agoI believe DMCA also applies to circumvention tools. I don't personally agree that youtube-dl is a circumvention tool since all it does is emulate what your browser does anyway, but I presume that is the argument.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>believe DMCA also applies to circumvention tools. There is a separate section of the DMCA that deals with circumvention tools requiring a court order to take them down. DMCA takedown requests do not cover circumvention tools.
- kmeisthax 6y agoDMCA Section 1201 has a separate notice-and-takedown regime from DMCA Section 512 (the one most people think of when they hear "DMCA takedown").
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoCould you point to the portion of 1201 that has a notice-and-takedown regime at all, as opposed to the ordinary default of the plaintiff needing a court order (which the RIAA hadn't bothered to get)?
- dylan604 6y agoYou must have missed the whole DeCSS debacle. That was code that absolutely was meant to circumvent an encryption protection scheme regardless of how weak its encryption was. They went so far as to print the source code of DeCSS on t-shirts[0] as first amendment gestures after that code was deemed enemy number 1. [0] a 20 year old article: https://www.wired.com/2000/08/court-to-address-decss-t-shirt/ https://www.wired.com/2000/08/court-to-address-decss-t-shirt...
- phendrenad2 6y agoThis is a gross misremembering of how DeCSS went down. They didn't just print "source code" on shirts, they very specifically printed the "magic number" that the MPAA was claiming was copyrighted CONTENT, not a circumvention device.
- dlgeek 6y agoYou're conflating DeCSS (which GP post was describing) and the AACS encryption key debacle which came later.
- dylan604 6y agoWho's grossly misremembering what? CSS was the encryption scheme attempting to protect DVDs. AACS was the encryption for Blu-ray. DeCSS could defeat CSS encryption because it was so weak. AACS was defeated because the master key that generated all other keys was discovered [0]. That's the magic number to which you are referring. Totally different subjects on somewhat similar topics. These 2 cases were separated by years. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AACS_encryption_key_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AACS_encryption_key_controvers...
- musicale 6y agoThe comparison with DeCSS doesn't make a lot of sense since youtube-dl was not decrypting anything. Regardless, since DMCA takedowns are for infringing content, isn't EFF's point valid, namely that there was no infringing content?
- zucker42 6y agoUnfortunately, companies have to respond to even grossly incorrect DMCA requests to avoid liability and there's no recourse against abusive requests.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Unfortunately, companies have to respond to even grossly incorrect DMCA requests to avoid liability No, they don't, because if they are grossly incorrect, there's no liability to avoid. They have to respond to even grossly incorrect though facially valid DMCA requests to avoid the costs of trying to evaluate whether DMCA requests that are facially invalid are sufficiently grossly incorrect as to present no real risk of liability. > there's no recourse against abusive requests. Sure there is, civil action for defamation