3 ms·

No, they are different. Unlike LVT, an appreciation tax is a transaction tax, which can be shifted to the purchasers.

• bhupy 6y ago
  I would argue that as a transaction tax, it reduces the demand for the land. The net effect is the same: curbing land speculation.
  • typ 6y ago
    A transaction tax does not reduce the demand. It reduces the quantity of transactions that matches the demand and supply. That means it adds friction to the reallocation of resources for more efficient use. It literally encourages hoarding. That is even worse than speculation.
    • bhupy 6y ago
      Why is it that traditional capital gains tax doesn’t function as a transaction tax on equities and securities?
      • typ 6y ago
        I am not sure what you mean by "doesn't function as a traction tax". It does create the same incentive for hoarding. I don't see any advantage of it compared with LVT.