2 ms·
> Secure Equifax data for SSN, Names, Addresses What does this mean? > The only hitch here is matching a signature to the voter registration, which if I were
by smt88 6y ago
> Secure Equifax data for SSN, Names, Addresses
What does this mean?
> The only hitch here is matching a signature to the voter registration, which if I were an enterprising lad, might be easy, no?
No. Even if signature-matching were a legitimate process, it's still not easy to see someone's signature.
The real hitch here is that this doesn't scale. Even if you pull it off perfectly, it's:
- expensive
- difficult
- easily discovered by the voter
- possibly fruitless if the voter was on your side already
And even if you could make it scale, you'd have to have massive scale to actually sway an important election. You don't know ahead of time which counties (or even states!) will be crucial to the election. You can guess, but you can't narrow it down to one.
So if I were trying to sway the current presidential election, I would have had to alter 10,000+ votes in multiple states. If my success rate (meaning I'm not discovered) is 50%, suddenly I had to alter 20,000 votes.
Once you get to election fraud of that size, you become pretty easy to find, and someone is likely to notice and find you.
> Identify which are least likely to vote
This part is also impossible. If it were possible, polls would be a lot more accurate.
- throwyacct 6y ago> Secure Equifax data for SSN, Names, Addresses > What does this mean? I have to imagine it means that since Equifax was hacked and the personal information has been copied in other locations to verify if individuals have been pwned - that it makes it on the easier scale for a powerful organization to acquire. > Expensive I don't think a dollar amount can be put on the economical impact of 'influencing' some high profile elections. > Difficult See above. > Easily discovered by the voter This point will address the 'impossibility' of identifying likely voters - this information is actually what ground campaigns rely on and update on a daily basis in local elections. There are companies that offer this information by analyzing voter rolls based on campaign themes and much more - the data is there, the usual 'game theory' is you only focus on turning out your base and doing what you can for undecideds. > So if I were trying to sway the current presidential election, I would have had to alter 10,000+ votes in multiple states. If my success rate (meaning I'm not discovered) is 50%, suddenly I had to alter 20,000 votes. OP must mean 'easy' for a large organization, or coordinated effort, not a one off individual. Finally, I agree on the idea that 'there should be smoke' - we would be seeing many people show up to the polls only to discover they have 'already voted' or 'received a ballot by mail' - and those people would be making a fuss. The question is how credible the unlikely voter information in the current polling and political strategy services.
- smt88 6y ago> I don't think a dollar amount can be put on the economical impact of 'influencing' some high profile elections. Sure it can. Let's say the cost of a TV ad campaign is $100M, and you expect to get an extra 1,000 votes out of it. Now let's say the cost of elections fraud, an extremely serious offense, is $100k + 75% chance of going to prison. That $100M suddenly sounds a lot better to most people. We can't know whether it's 1% or 75%, but unless you're very smart and conspire with a very small group of people, it wouldn't be hard to catch you. At the very least, you'd be on camera visiting your post office boxes (which you can't use to register to vote in some places anyway). > This point will address the 'impossibility' of identifying likely voters I didn't say it's impossible to guess likely voters. It's impossible to guess highly unlikely voters. Likely voters follow a pattern: they voted before. Once someone votes, they're likely to vote again. Unlikely voters could just start voting in any election (as they did in this year's) without any warning. There's no psychographic or demographic information that's widely available to hackers to help them decide which unlikely voters will continue to be non-voters.