4 ms·
Or better yet, CEOs should not buyout competitors to eliminate threats.
by prepend 6y ago
Or better yet, CEOs should not buyout competitors to eliminate threats.
- x3c 6y agoWhy not?
- prepend 6y agoBecause it’s anticompetitive, bad for users, and sometimes against US law. Like when you’re as big as Visa.
- steve918 6y agoBecause it's the definition of anti-competitive actions.
- amcoastal 6y agoMaybe a CEO "should" because it's good for them and their company, but a healthy market regulator "should not" allow those type of transactions, in general, for the good of market participants.
- cle 6y agoI agree about your being specific about these types of transactions. At this scale, these things should be blocked. In healthier marketplaces, acquisitions can also improve the overall health of the marketplace by improving efficiency, output, etc., while maintaining competition. The interesting question to me in these discussions is, are there systemic changes we can make that would prevent these marketplace distortions from being possible in the first place, and what would be the negative tradeoffs? And are they politically feasible?
- vmception 6y agowell I mean, don't say that's why you are buying them out.
- ehsankia 6y agoOr again, don't do it in the first place.
- vmception 6y agoBut also, still buy them out for billions.
- SilasX 6y agoShareholder call: CEO: "And for our strategy over the next year, we will consider buying a controlling interest in Plaid..." Icahn-type shareholder: "Really? Why? It would cost a fortune! What's the value proposition there?" CEO: "Because Plaid has a cool ... name ...?"
- vmception 6y agoThat could fly, something like the brand name is good and is cheaper than the licensing fees they had offered And just repeat growth over and over again
- salawat 6y agoThat's also misrepresenting material facts (in my view, which matters diddly squat in a courtroom without the right lawyer), and lying by omission. The fact that "proving" malintent in the U.S. in M&A's and market shaping revolves around someone finding a rather fiendishly worded memo is somewhat laughable. >"You can't prove I was going to take a cookie! Maybe I just like having my hand in the jar!" If it would get the stink eye from my Mom, the same argument form should not be considered a valid approach to business or legality.
- SilasX 6y agoFair enough, maybe not the best example. The point is just that they'd have to beat around the bush and not be able to give a good enough reason that justifies a solid buyout price without admitting the monopolist strategy.
- vkou 6y agoWhy not? It's the natural consequence of wealth accumulation in free market economies. Not everyone has the same warchest, and money is a great moat for inefficient or rent-seeking businesses. Being able to outspend your competitors is kind of the point of having it.