3 ms·
This whole thing makes me think of how Google goes "above and beyond" with Content ID on YouTube. Google had no legal obligation to build Content ID and preemp
by kelnos 6y ago
This whole thing makes me think of how Google goes "above and beyond" with Content ID on YouTube. Google had no legal obligation to build Content ID and preemptively take things down (and, as it turns out, way more aggressively than they legally need to be).
In the same way, it seems GitHub is preemptively telling people that if they re-post youtube-dl on GH, they'll be banned, even though GH has no legal responsibility to do so. It's really sad that they're siding with big business in all this, rather than their users, without whom they'd be nothing.
- TheKarateKid 6y agoYouTube had to make Content ID because they were facing a multi-billion dollar lawsuit from Viacom. Had YouTube not been proactive, the court could have ruled that YouTube was widely used for piracy, and they’d be liable. GitHub seems to be acting without a backbone. They’re owned by Microsoft, and can definitely stand up to legal challenges like this. Look at BitTorrent: The protocol and it’s code are legal despite being used for piracy. I don’t see why GitHub caves to every request to take down code that is clearly not violating any copyrighted material. Also, the code itself does not break any copy protection and even if it did.. the code itself needs a user to execute it. Isn’t this how LAME was able to exist without violating mp3 patent laws?