3 ms·
Say I'm Catholic, and I oppose abortion because that's church doctrine. OK, that's religious. But say I'm an atheist, and I think that a fetus is genetically
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
Say I'm Catholic, and I oppose abortion because that's church doctrine. OK, that's religious. But say I'm an atheist, and I think that a fetus is genetically human and also genetically a different individual from the mother, and I think that that implies that it has human rights and can't just be killed for someone else's convenience. That's the same position, but now it's not religious.
That is, I think that every conviction that a person can have for religious reasons (at least, every one that affects politics or society), people can have the same convictions for non-religious reasons. I see no valid reason for saying that the non-religious ones are "less valid" than secular ones, or that secular ones should win by default.
Now let's say that here's a Catholic university. I'm an atheist, and I want to be the president of that university. They're going to say "no way", and I don't get to claim discrimination, because they're religious.
But let's say there's a Haskell Foundation, and I want to be president of that, even though I'm a hard-core C++ bigot. They are also going to say "no way", but they're going to say "incompatible with our goals as a foundation" or something. But it seems to me to still be quite similar. People who don't believe in the identity of your organization are a bad fit for positions of authority in your organization.
- JabavuAdams 6y agoThe problem is that for the vast majority of people religious beliefs are instilled while they are children, within a cultural context, and are empirically harder to change than things like programming language preference. For many, they're not even open to discussion. That's in fact why there are religious protections. It's simply unrealistic to expect people to give up their upbringing just to get a certain job. You identify the problem in your paragraph re: Haskell. Suppose I want to set up some organization working to start a new polity. Let's say that as a baseline, I want to recruit people who think it is wrong to resort to violence over say cartoons that are offensive to their religious beliefs. Or maybe I want to recruit people who have no desire to bar people of different sexual orientations from fully participating in love and social life. I can't do that in the current legal system because religious beliefs are a protected class. I understand why we got here, historically, but now that we're not burning people at the stake, I don't see why their religious beliefs should supersede the larger societal norms (of a new society). It's a matter of how strongly those beliefs are held and the futility of trying to convince people to abandon such deeply-held and meaningful beliefs. Better to tilt the scales by not inviting them to the party, regardless of which way things evolve later. EDIT> For any given religion I recognize that there are many possible doctrinal and individual interpretations. But how to measure the individual's preferences as a filter on admission? It's easy to fake answers to a questionnaire. How to establish an org without inviting the griefers, and without running afoul of protected classes? I mean you could do it the old-fashioned nudge-nudge-wink-wink way, but that's a huge legal vulnerability.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoWell, if you're establishing your own country, a "huge legal vulnerability" is not an issue, because you're creating a new legal system. But I take issue with: > Better to tilt the scales by not inviting them to the party, regardless of which way things evolve later. Just assume, for purposes of argument, that in 100 or 200 years people view abortion the way we now view eugenics - as a horror committed in the name of "progress". And assume that abortion was one of the issues that you "tilted the scales by not inviting" the pro-life people to your new country. Doing so put you behind, rather than ahead (in this thought experiment). The value of excluding the people who think differently is highly dependent on how sure you are that your direction is in fact correct.
- JabavuAdams 6y agoWell, the point is that non-religious beliefs even if strongly held and the norm are more easily changeable than religious ones. If I argue with you over your non-religious beliefs I may be annoying, but I'm not attacking your whole way of being. If I argue your religious beliefs than there's a lower threshold for me being an asshole, and a lower expectation of being able to sway you. Rather than religious / non-religious the fundamental distinction is how open to debate and effectively changeable those beliefs are. It's just that, empirically, religious beliefs are harder to sway. They also have greater protection under the law than non-religious beliefs.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoFair point.