4 ms·
Agreed. I do not agree with decriminalising the trade in drugs, but criminalising their possession for personal use is a really important practical step in figh
by simonh 6y ago
Agreed. I do not agree with decriminalising the trade in drugs, but criminalising their possession for personal use is a really important practical step in fighting the trade in hard drugs and reducing addiction rates for many reasons.
It decouples the interests of drug traffickers from those of users making users more likely to cooperate with law enforcement, frees up social workers and medical professionals from the risk of criminal liability for associating with drug users in possession of or using drugs. It also makes it easier to address incidental associated health issue such as infections from dirty needles. Treating it as a health issue destigmatises it making it easier for users to talk about it and seek help.
This is not theoretical, this is from actual findings from countries like Portugal the Netherlands and Norway where trading in hard drugs is still illegal but possession and use are treated as public health issues. This is a policy that works.
- dotandgtfo 6y agoFully agree with you, I just want to point out that Norway has a very strict stance against all drugs, so much so that you can lose your drivers license for having cannabis metabolites in your blood due too a lack of "soberness". It's mental.
- simonh 6y agoI think it's really important to dissociate supporting decriminalisation of possession and use from being "pro drugs". They are very much not the same thing.
- wayneftw 6y ago> I do not agree with decriminalising the trade in drugs. Why not? Do you support criminal cartels making lots of money off of them or do you think that the War on Drugs will actually get rid of that criminal element which profits from them at some point? I don't see a problem with anyone putting anything they want into their own body. Arrest them when they commit an actual victim-ful crime like stealing but not before that. To that end, I say sell them with regulation just like Alcohol. Keeping sales illegal means questionable sources, questionable quality and enormous profits for criminal gangs.
- rv-de 6y agowhat he says. criminalization should be reserved to actions which cause harm to another person who didn't agree to the respective interaction. If an adult decides to take a drug - fine. If another adult sells a drug to another adult - where's the problem? OTOH I'd like to see the concept of mitigating circumstances removed in criminal justice. If somebody takes a drug and commits a crime - full responsibility.
- tartoran 6y agoIn an ideal world theres no problem but the reality is murkier. Im thinking of crime against vulnerable people, especially that these drugs impair one’s senses. I’d like drug trading to be legal but heavily regulated and the enforcement taken seriously. It would also do a very good thing to educate people about the risks of addiction, the simptoms of it and where to ask for help for it.
- ranbumo 6y agoConsent is a tricky issue when it comes to drugs. You could even argue that consent isn't possible when you are heavily addicted.
- mam2 6y agoBecause heroin is a poison, and the whole "i do what i want with my body" hides the fact that young adult often will just try random stuff just because its available and / or their friends do it. Its not 100% rational free will.
- sixQuarks 6y agoThis is a terrible reason for making something illegal. Alcohol is just as bad, why not just introduce age limits like alcohol?
- tartoran 6y agoI think heroin has much higher dangers and usually the accidenal deaths are very swift and come from nowhere. Alcohol on the other hand kills a lot more people but because it does so slowly they have higher chance to pick themselves up, go to detox, AA, etc