4 ms·
Not long ago I worked at a big name tech company and with someone who interacted with folks who reported security concerns. Half the time the security team was
by duxup 6y ago
Not long ago I worked at a big name tech company and with someone who interacted with folks who reported security concerns.
Half the time the security team was scrambling to prevent various people from sending legal on a crusade to attack the latest researcher who responsibly told them about a security issue. It only got better after legal was educated enough to not just shoot from the hip with threats... but really they were just acting like a firewall for much of the management team who saw any such disclosure as some sort of attack.
And this was a tech company, everything they did was technology, located in the valley... they still didn't get it.
Even just getting these researchers token recognition (many asked for almost nothing) was an uphill battle.
One of the challenges was that the folks on the security team were really passionate about doing the right thing and they didn't want to break relationships they had with researchers / the community. They were prone to leave companies who were bad at handling those relationships ... leaving bad companies with fewer such people and accordingly things would fester.
The security industry is full of straight up charlatans and legit people. The legit people are super sensitive about being associated with charlatans and thus the charlatans are often left to their own devices after the legit folks run for cover (elsewhere).
For the record this is my perception from working with security minded folks, and not actually working in that industry myself.
- nerdponx 6y agoWhat incentive does legal even have for acting this way? Internal commendations? Bonuses?
- duxup 6y agoI never had a good view of what their motivations were. Honestly I've found legal groups in companies to be generally pretty secretive. But I'm inclined to think to start that groups in a company are incentivized to do what they think their job is... bring something to legal, they'll have a legal type answer. Bring something to the engineers, you'll get some code. Need a customer to stop clicking a button? Engineering will code it to be disabled at times. Legal will demand a prompt with a legal agreement you have to check before the action takes place. HR might even come up with some training classes ;)
- dyingkneepad 6y agoIf your only tool is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_the_instrument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_the_instrument
- Angostura 6y agoIt feels akin to a rogue immune response that threatens the patient.
- Spooky23 6y agoSometimes folks have a thought process or philosophical approach towards risk management where having the ability to not know about a problem is more important than the problem itself. Other times, you become aware of the problem and need to decide how to deal with it. Chase is a global bank with ~200k employees. There's always issues, most of which are fairly minor/low-risk financially, but may have significant reputational or other impacts. In this scenario, you have counsel and risk management people looking at a scenario where a guy basically stole $5,000 from the bank, due to an error on the part of the bank. They don't give a flying leap about the error -- it's not their job to care, the event becomes the problem. $5,000 from an FDIC institution is a very serious crime. My guess is that the internal discussion was filing a criminal complaint and exposing their dirty laundry in court, or cutting the losses and severing the relationship. But the guy in question here did something really dumb, was very lucky, and should stfu.
- joshuaissac 6y ago> But the guy in question here did something really dumb, was very lucky, and should stfu. What did he do wrong? He already had permission from Chase: > But because this was a bank I wanted to get their explicit permission before researching any further > Once I had permission quickly made a proof of concept So I would be surprised if they would be able to make the criminal charges stick.
- bb88 6y agoIANAL, but I thought fraud was the act itself plus the intent to defraud. Otherwise simple accounting errors would be criminal acts.
- austhrow743 6y agoIf he did, that twitter screenshot certainly isn't it. That's them asking for more information about a points glitch, not telling him to steal $5000 from them.
- astura 6y agoNot sure what it was about that response on twitter that made him think he had permission to do what he did.
- crmd 6y agoIt’s an organizational/professional culture issue. Lawyers are trained to instinctively operate and communicate in a way that seems outrageous and like straight up bullying to reasonable non-lawyer colleagues, but seems to them perfectly reasonable and simply being competent at their job. I think this disconnect is a big part of why lawyers hold such a reviled place in polite society.