3 ms·
> When you pass a law that affects so many ordinary people, you better be sure that's what they want The reason we have a representative democracy is because s
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> When you pass a law that affects so many ordinary people, you better be sure that's what they want
The reason we have a representative democracy is because sometimes legislators can make decisions that might be different from the typical voter who has not spent extensive time thinking about the issue.
- sida 6y agoAnd the counter-argument would be that the reason for possibilities of direct democracy is for situations like this where unions have achieved regulatory capture, such that a small number of people wield disproportionate influence and drive the legislature against what the people want
- mdorazio 6y agoI have a hard time believing that claim when Uber and Lyft were massively abusing their own platforms and public reach to run bullshit campaigns on behalf of Prop 22. California's proposition system also doesn't have a great track record of enacting legislation that's actually a good thing in hindsight.
- whimsicalism 6y agoI think it's hard to seriously claim that there is regulatory capture of the legislature by unions in America, but okay. > such that a small number of people wield disproportionate influence and drive the legislature against what the people want Much better to have Uber wield its disproportionate influence to display push notifications telling me to vote for Prop 22 every day leading up to the election.
- chmod600 6y agoAre you sure the Assembly knows best? Drivers can't be on-the-clock for two employers at the same time. So drivers who use both Uber and Lyft would have to choose. That means the customers outside of major urban centers would be less likely to find a driver nearby, because they may be looking in Uber and the driver is on-the-clock with Lyft. It seems like the effect would end up being monopolistic because the network effects would be even stronger than they are now. That would be compounded by the lack of drivers. Market stickiness of the employment relationship would drive the equilibrium of drivers down, wait times up, prices up, and riders down.
- chmod600 6y agoWe also have special interest groups that do their research and endorse or oppose these propositions. Mothers Against Drunk Driving endorsed Prop 22. If the state Assembly didn't see that one coming, they really screwed up.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoGood point. I’d forgotten about how rideshare had removed a lot of drunks from the roads.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoThose same reps changed their minds and carved out tons of “whoops that’s not what we meant” exemptions, which is presumably what that comment is referring to with “you better be sure that’s what they want.”