4 ms·
The market is doing its best to counter Trump's efforts here, as renewables and storage are dropping faster in price than anybody expected, even the biggest boo
by epistasis 6y ago
The market is doing its best to counter Trump's efforts here, as renewables and storage are dropping faster in price than anybody expected, even the biggest boosters of the tech. We will never build another coal plant in the US. And our energy is getting cheaper, and the grid will get more reliable as we distribute more storage through it.
And fortunately for the environment, Trump's efforts at the DoE to help coal have been staggeringly incompetent and ineffective. But I fear that in the past four years, the administration might have found some lawyers that understand the basics of how executive branches can legally execute given the laws that gave them executive powers.
- kortilla 6y ago> We will never build another coal plant in the US. Because of natural gas, not renewables. Renewables still need base load due to variable generation because storage technology isn’t economical. If the price of natural gas didn’t collapse due to fracking the fuck out of the whole country for the last 15 years, we would still be building coal plants hand over fist.
- bluGill 6y agoTrue, but misleading. Last year Iowa got more than 60% of their electric from renewable sources (almost entirely wind). The natural gas plants are not for base load, but for backup when the wind isn't blowing.
- kortilla 6y ago> gas plants are not for base load, but for backup when the wind isn't blowing. That’s base load. If you didn’t have the gas plants you would have had rolling outages, which means it’s providing base load. Perhaps you are confusing them with peaker plants, which are to help during high demand.
- epistasis 6y agoIn the future, which again, is what we are talking about when we are talking about the Paris Accords, gas will serve as a backup source for extended wind droughts. However, we will need to provide some subsidies to keep these gas plants around, because within a decade it will not be economical to operate them unless markets are redesigned to properly compensate combined cycle gas turbines that operate at <25% capacity factor.
- kortilla 6y agoWell they don’t need to be subsidized, the energy market just needs to allow prices to spike during the troughs. That will pay for gas while simultaneously incentivizing even more storage.
- epistasis 6y agoWith the Paris Accord, we are talking about the future, not the last 15 years. And for the future, renewables + storage is cheaper than natural gas. We can get to 80% renewables cheaply. And as the modelers update their cost curves to adapt to the pace of storage's learning curve, we will be able to get to 90% renewables cheaply, then 95%, then 100% as we start to decarbonize the non-electrical parts of our economy. And though there were tax incentives that helped build the industry, and help from countries like Germany that decided to start buying the expensive first generation products in order to drive down prices, the end result is that we are now living in a world where tech has changed the economic landscape. The cheapest grids to be build will not be based on fossil fuels. Developing countries will be able to build renewables+storage based micro grids far more cheaply than they will build traditional wires + thermal heat engines. And places with the wealth to do long term investing will be able to build long distance transmission to distribute cheap renewables with less storage.
- kortilla 6y ago> And for the future, renewables + storage is cheaper than natural gas. Sigh, there is no evidence of this or projects yet planned based on full renewable that uses storage to account for generation troughs. The storage gap is significant right now and making solar panels so cheap that labor and transmission are 99% of the cost won’t help that.
- epistasis 6y agoDon't sigh yet, there is ample evidence in the markets that storage is making serious inroads. In the ERCOT market in Texas, where rules have recently changed to allow storage into the grid as both supply and load, there are absolutely massive amounts of projects in the pipeline. Since it's one of the most open markets, anybody can go and download all the projects that are at any point of the connection process. Last month, there were 18GW of storage planned for Texas alone. Interconnection only cares about power, not energy, so we only no GW and not GWh for these projects at the moment. The energy capacity in MWh only comes into play as they bid on the market to sell or buy energy. ERCOT is only the most transparent energy market, which is why I mention it first, but other markets are also seeing massive amounts of storage planned in the coming years. The other most open electricity market, PJM, shows a similar surge of renewables and storage: https://cleantechnica.com/2020/10/03/rocky-mountain-institute-study-shows-renewables-are-kicking-natural-gas-to-the-curb/ https://cleantechnica.com/2020/10/03/rocky-mountain-institut... On the rest of the US grids, which are more centrally planned by monopoly utilities, we need to be sure that regulations actually reward the cheapest energy if we want renewables and storage to win. Typically (but not always) regulators allow the monopoly utility to take a fixed percentage of costs as profit, so monopoly utilities are incentivized to choose higher cost options for supplying electricity. Storage alone doesn't care about where the electricity is coming from, so these storage projects from the grid are planned based on any sort of time arbitrage, grid congestion relief, or frequency regulation reimbursement people think they can get. This is based purely on people's bets with their own capital and what they think the market will look like. Academic estimates and monopoly central planning is far far more conservative in storage than people spending their own money.