7 ms·
Wouldn't happen in a world where the DOJ forces Apple to open up the platform to 3rd party installs. It's a computer, and the most popular computer in the US.
by echelon 6y ago
Wouldn't happen in a world where the DOJ forces Apple to open up the platform to 3rd party installs.
It's a computer, and the most popular computer in the US. It's also the only computer a lot of people own.
It's not a dedicated gaming device - people use iPhone to call, edit media, find jobs, pay for things, calculate, date, do email. It's a computer. Arguments like "but you can't install on a Nintendo" aren't equivalent. Nintendo makes one of a dozen different game platforms, all of which have wide penetration and lots of alternatives. And it's just for games. This is closer to "you can't repair your tractor", which is also an issue for farmers.
Computers, especially those with massive market share, should be open to 3rd party installs.
It's an expensive device and it got to where it is because of a trillion dollar company backing it. You can't compete with that.
You own an iPhone and you're happy installing just from Apple? That's fine. But there are a lot more people in this world that will benefit from open computing. Apple can still have their App Store, charge for distribution, and will still be making bank.
Computing on computers should be free and open.
If we let this slide, we'll one day own nothing. Stallman was right about everything.
- alexvoda 6y agoNote: all console generations so far had the option of loading software from physical media (even if there are models without this option, they are not the only model). As long as physical media is an alternative for loading software on consoles, consoles are not as restrictive as iOS devices (even if creation of that physical media requires licensing 1'st party development tools). Apple iOS is the only platform where a company uses its natural monopoly over the hardware and OS to create a monopoly on software distribution.
- russli1993 6y agono, on consoles, the platform holder has to approve every single game to be made into discs. If your game violates Sony and Microsoft's rules, they won't let you make the discs. Its same with the app store.
- alexvoda 6y agoThose restrictions are made through use of trademarks, limiting access to development tools through contracts and code signing. First can be sidestepped by not mentioning the trademarks of the platform holder anywhere. The second can be side stepped through reverse engineering. Third can eventually be hacked out of the device (like the recent encryption key reveal on Intel CPU's) and was not applicable to older generations. Proof of 1 and 2 is the existence of new games developed for ancient consoles. https://www.syfy.com/syfywire/the-unlikely-but-very-real-resurgence-of-video-game-cartridges https://www.syfy.com/syfywire/the-unlikely-but-very-real-res...
- Someone 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_signing#Unsigned_code_in_gaming_and_consumer_devices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_signing#Unsigned_code_in_...: “Most console games have to be signed with a secret key designed by the console maker or the game will not load on the console. There are several methods to get unsigned code to execute which include software exploits, the use of a modchip, a technique known as the swap trick or running a softmod.” I don’t see how iOS is different here.
- machello13 6y agoAren't all of those also true with iOS? Have you heard of Jailbreaking?
- alexvoda 6y agoOf course I heard of Jailbreaking. The difference was that jailbreaking and modding consoles requires modified hardware to run unapproved software (digitally distributed). But reverse engineering the development tools and the signing keys in order to create unapproved disks or cartridges is a viable method to create software for unmodified devices. See FreeDVDBoot for the PS2.
- machello13 6y agoJailbreaking definitely does not require modified hardware. You also don't need to jailbreak to install 3rd party apps. See http://altstore.io/ http://altstore.io/.
- mikecsh 6y agoDon't most consoles require the software loaded from said physical media to be made with the manufactuer's SDK and signed by their private key?
- alexvoda 6y agoFurthermore, Apple is using their created monopoly on software distribution to create a monopoly on payments. Even if you disagree with me on the first part (platform -> distribution) I know of no other case where the second part is also true (distribution -> payments). Goggle may try to impose Google Pay for in-app payments but they do not have the a monopoly on distribution (F-droid, Amazon, Aptoid, etc. exist).
- maratc 6y ago“Well plaintiffs always want me to define relevant markets as narrowly as possible. It helps their case. And defendants always want me to define markets as broad as possible, because it helps their case.” — Judge YGR on Epic/Apple case.
- alexvoda 6y agoIn the end it will depend on the judge to define the markets. But I am of the firm opinion that iOS devices and Android devices are not interchangeable even if you can do many of the same things on both and many apps are available on both platforms. Just because a hatchback, a big rig and a personal airplane all get you from A to B while seated and all have air conditioning and entertainment systems does not make them fungible.
- enos_feedler 6y agoDefine computing. I am free to write and distribute computation via Javascript in Safari. Should computing be lower level? How low? From the bootchain? Who decides at what layer “free computing” should be wedged into a product? Why can’t Apple make that decision for themselves?
- DarkWiiPlayer 6y agoWell... you can completely reprogram the device, if you have the tools and knowledge for it. Apple has no obligation to make this process easy or even possible, and if the users still buy their products, they clearly don't care enough about these restrictions.
- alexvoda 6y agoNot caring is precisely the problem. A problem that leads to erosion of ownership. And this leads to a form of communism. Apple, Google, etc. are in some ways similar to the state in communist regimes. They own everything but they promise to give you fair access until they don't.
- enos_feedler 6y agoI don't think it is about "not caring". Apple cares intensely about the products they build taking into the needs of their addressable market. There are 1000s of product decisions made between inception and distribution into your hands. I don't believe that the one decision around open and free programmability of native OS-level applications has any association with ownership to them.
- alexvoda 6y agoI am referring to the customers not caring about whether they truly own the devices they buy.
- chacha2 6y agoHow is a capitalist monopoly communism? These operating systems are the companies private property, they can do what they want with them. The only way to prevent them is by abolishing their property and putting them in the public domain.
- DarkWiiPlayer 6y ago> Computers, especially those with massive market share, should be open to 3rd party installs. Why? If you don't like it, don't buy their product. I think iPhone is shit because of this, and other tactics to lock the user in, so I don't use it and wouldn't recommend it to anybody.
- mavhc 6y agoMaybe iOS devices should come with a big warning label like cigarettes: Warning: Apple solely controls what apps you can run on this device
- alexvoda 6y agoI find that to be a fair proposal.
- DarkWiiPlayer 6y agoThe problem is: Installing software on a phone hasn't ever been "normal" before a few years ago, and since then, it has never really been about installing any random program like it is on PC. We're right in the middle of shift of perspective where smart-phones stop being just cellphones with some extra features but actually peoples main access to general computing. But to many they still are just "phones", and tech companies are taking advantage of this situation to shape the mentality around them in a different way than with desktop computing. This is their right, although it's obviously evil. It's the media (tech magazines, youtube channels, etc.) that should be clearing up these misconceptions, but the sad reality is, people don't care. If I try explaining to a non-IT friend why installing any random software is essential, they look at me like I'm wearing a tin foil hat. People don't understand how quickly computation is turning into an important aspect of freedom.
- mhh__ 6y agoI think relying on perfect information from the consumer is a little naive? It's easy to (say) find the phone with the best camera, but you never know you need freedom until it's too late.
- pmiller2 6y agoFYI (or, maybe not -- you seem to know what's going on already), there's a subreddit literally called "Stallman Was Right: https://www.reddit.com/r/StallmanWasRight/ https://www.reddit.com/r/StallmanWasRight/