4 ms·
"extracting the excess heat" is nice. Unless there is some other path to conversion of the fusion energy to "useful" energy, this heat is the primary mechanism:
by ggm 6y ago
"extracting the excess heat" is nice. Unless there is some other path to conversion of the fusion energy to "useful" energy, this heat is the primary mechanism: you drive a heat exchanger, to drive a turbine, to make electricity. This is what we want: excess heat, to drive a turbine.
Clearly, this tokomak isn't going to make net positive contribution to energy delivery. Some future (30 years?) tokomak is meant to do it.
I do get that for an experiment, "extracting" the heat is what its all about.
(Happy to be put right by wiser heads, if there is some other path to useful energy out from fusion)
- ggm 6y agoI read up, the two other choices are fusion-fission driving: use the neutrons to activate fissionable materials and then put them into a classic fission reactor as food (not what we want really) and direct electic extraction of surplus charge, which is at 48% efficiency according to the wiki. So yes: surplus heat is likely to be one of the useful products but not the only one, and if 48% efficiency is acceptable, it might be better to do direct charge take-off and process the heat as a problem as a much as the solution to a problem. Once the heat isn't a problem, its useful. You can have a hot bath. Or feed tomato roots in a greenhouse. Or I guess, run a turbine...
- j9461701 6y agoAchieving fusion would be a god-send, but aneutronic fusion - which is generally considered 'the next step' - would be utterly spectacular. First, it would save you having to build very expense and complex steam turbines. Like Chernobyl had 4 nuclear reactors powering 1 steam turbine, because the engineering required to build a high quality high capacity one is super expensive. With aneutronic fusion you could just use the energy from the generated charged particles and directly turn that into juice. The huge, huge, huge thing though would be no more neutron radiation. It would vastly simplify reactor construction, reactor cleanup, biological shielding, etc. etc. Aneutronic fusion would also us to just spam power plants, safely and cheaply, in a way that's difficult for modern society to even understand. Assuming the aneutronic reactor itself isn't mega expense of course.
- arethuza 6y agoI'm pretty sure the Chernobyl plant had 4 separate "blocks" each with one reactor and two turbo generators? No.4 was the one that exploded but the other three kept on producing power for years after. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_Nuclear_Power_Plant
- j9461701 6y agoYou're totally correct. It was 4 reactor buildings feeding one turbine house, but the house contained two turbo generators. Thanks for the correction!
- gameshot911 6y agoAneurotnic fusion sounds like exciting stuff. Are there any pilots in development? Is it realistically achievable at the moment (well, as realistic as any fusion efforts), or still in the realm of room-temperature superconductors?
- raducu 6y agoWhy do you need to put those neutrons in a fission reactor? Neutrons would still be absorbed and produce heat. Is it because those neutrons damage the reactor structure?
- ggm 6y agoyes. aneutreonic, a reaction with "less" neutrons would be cleaner. either you have less/no neutrons, or you absorb the neutrons you have. they make the structure radioactive and/or change it chemically (embrittlement) or, you absorb them into other things to make them radioactive, and useful. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_embrittlement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_embrittlement