3 ms·
OP overlooks the real reason people have leaned toward the bigger house for the past 50 years (and it has nothing to do with bathrooms or Grandma). It was beca
by edw519 18y ago
OP overlooks the real reason people have leaned toward the bigger house for the past 50 years (and it has nothing to do with bathrooms or Grandma). It was because it was generally accepted financial advice and because it worked.
The general rule was "Buy the biggest house you can afford, and then, when the time is right (5 years or so), take your equity or flip, and do it again. By retirement time, you should be sitting on a tidy next egg."
A lot of older baby boomers have earned more in their lifetime from this strategy that from all their jobs combined!
Then people forgot about the phrase "you can afford" and starting breaking the guidelines in a boom market. They also forgot about the busts, when this strategy goes on hold.
When you blindly follow "rules" you don't understand, you're just an accident waiting to happen.
- SwellJoe 18y agoIt's always seemed like that general rule was a not so subtle way of saying, "you cannot possibly be trusted to manage your assets responsibly, so you should tie them up in a house, so you can't do anything stupid with your money". Certainly real estate is historically a reasonable investment, but almost never the best one. And the additional upkeep costs: new roof every 7-10 years, lawn care, time spent cleaning 1000 extraneous sq feet of rooms, the opportunity cost of all that extra crap to fill up your McMansion, plumbing, electrical, etc. It's also worth thinking about the fact that if you followed the trend of the past ~20 years, and moved further out of the city with each new "upgrade", the reasonably sized house you left first is probably more valuable than the McMansion you live in now, because people are returning to cities and paying more for that convenience. And the suburban mega houses are steadily dropping in price. But, I agree. It all really went pair-shaped when people imagined themselves getting rich by flipping houses, and so spent more than they could afford--imagining that they'd flip it before the mortgage payments caught up with them, and make huge profits. Calling it "gambling", and treating it the same way, would probably not be incorrect. I think it's the same mindset that gets people in trouble.