3 ms·
Fixed wing aircraft must have air moving along the wings in order for them to generate lift. In other words, the aircraft must always be moving through the air.
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
Fixed wing aircraft must have air moving along the wings in order for them to generate lift. In other words, the aircraft must always be moving through the air. If its speed drops below some minimum value, it will stall and drop out of the sky like a rock. This is also why they need runways in order to take off. They need to accelerate to a minimum speed in order to even get airborne.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V_speeds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V_speeds
Rotary wing aircraft use their engines to constantly move the wings through the air instead of moving the aircraft itself. So the wings are always generating lift and the aircraft is free to move in much more flexible patterns. A very useful maneuver is hovering in place: the aircraft is able to simply hold its position in the air. Since only the wings need to move to generate lift, the aircraft itself does not need to accelerate in order to take off and therefore a long runway is not necessary.
Civilian drones usually have rotary wings because this allows people to do useful things like having the drone stay in one place in order to film or photograph something. A fixed wing aircraft would have to establish a loitering pattern around an area in order to do the same thing. In other words, rotary wings can just hover in place while a fixed wing would have to fly around in circles.
Fixed wing aircraft are more fuel efficient. Rotary wing aircraft must constantly spend fuel in order to keep their wings spinning. They lose lift otherwise. A fixed wing aircraft would probably be able to glide great distances and even land safely even if it lost all engines in the middle of its flight.
- jaclaz 6y agoThere are also unpowered rotating wings. Maybe it is possible to combine a "normal" quadrirotor (for vertical takeoff and hovering) with a rotating wing aircraft, the autogyro: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autogyro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autogyro to save a lot of energy when traveling horizontally. There is actually this thing here that is already a sort of cross-breed between a helicopter and an autogyro: https://airialrobotics.com/ https://airialrobotics.com/ https://airialrobotics.com/gt20-gyrotrak/ https://airialrobotics.com/gt20-gyrotrak/
- matheusmoreira 6y agoThat's really cool! I've read about the use of autorotation but only in the case of emergencies. I had no idea there were entire aircraft based around the concept. Since the rotary wings are unpowered, the autogyro loses many of the properties that make the helicopter so valuable. It requires forward motion in order to move air through the unpowered rotary wings and maintain lift. Looks like they have propellers providing forward thrust just like fixed wing aircraft. The article also states that they're not capable of vertical take off and landing. They need a runway to accelerate just like fixed wing aircraft.
- jaclaz 6y agoYep, but you can still power (when needed) the rotating wing and un-power it when it is not needed (forward travel), that is the "breakthrough" (if it works) of the mentioned GT20: >Helicopter mode for hovering and slow forward flight any time >Gyrocopter mode for fixed wing fast flight and long distance See also gyrocopters: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a882megKhVM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a882megKhVM Now, in scale for drones, it may also be possible to have an always unpowered rotor (rotating wing) AND 4 (or 5/6[1]) more conventional small rotors for vertical take off/landing and hovering. [1] just thinking aloud, but it would probably be simpler to have four horizontal small rotors, like a "common" drone and an additional one or two vertical to provide trust forward like a traditional airplane or autogyro.