10 ms·
I'm wondering what is the point of this threat level measurement (other than to say "see? we're doing something"). To me it doesn't seem actionable in any way,
by Nextgrid 6y ago
I'm wondering what is the point of this threat level measurement (other than to say "see? we're doing something"). To me it doesn't seem actionable in any way, and if it was actionable (like significantly raising security), how would that help considering all the terrorists have to do is to wait for the level to go down (thus the security is lowered) before striking again?
Furthermore the threat level has never gone below "substantial" (which signifies that an attack is likely), so it's akin to "cry wolf" all the time - eventually everyone learns to ignore it and it stops being a useful metric (if it ever was one, that is).
- colordrops 6y agoThe terrorist threat has always been to scare people into trading freedom for "security", i.e. more control over the populace and more contracts for security subcontractors. You have more of a chance of being struck by lightning.
- op03 6y agoNot really. Sometimes it's just a default move leaders have to make to cover their ass. If you are in a position of responsibility, even for a small group, and the neighbouring building gets robbed or there is physical violence, people are going to start asking you about the security of your building. You can ofcourse ignore/reassure them if you have built up enough trust or social/political capital. If you haven't and there are a bunch of ambitious people eyeing your chair, good luck showing the group robbery stats.
- colordrops 6y agoThe analogy would make sense if it was lip service for a year rather than trillions of dollars and hundreds of thousands dead over the course of decades.
- mellosouls 6y agoIt's useful in that it raises the alert level in the general population (in addition to the more cynical motives posited by others). "crying wolf" or "alertness fatigue" might be an issue if this was a frequent thing, but it isn't. It also presumably can be timed to coincide with recent attacks when there is genuine intelligence; the events in the news acting as cover for the intelligence which doesn't necessarily need to be acknowledged as a reason for raising the level.
- neltnerb 6y agoAm I reading correctly that since 2006 it has never gone below "SUBSTANTIAL"? From their description: SUBSTANTIAL means an attack is likely SEVERE means an attack is highly likely CRITICAL means an attack is highly likely in the near future Saying an attack is at least "likely" for 14 straight years is definitely going to cause fatigue. I might be misunderstanding it and hopefully they just mean those specific days there was a risk and every other day they didn't think there was. But why then would they bother having a level for "LOW means an attack is highly unlikely" if they only flagged risky days? If it weren't constantly elevated wouldn't they flag the vast majority of dates as "LOW"? I think that no, they are flagging every day as having a terrorist attack "likely"!
- howlgarnish 6y agoBecause if a bureaucrat officially states that risk is LOW and an attack happens, that bureaucrat's own ass is now at risk. So keeping it at SUBSTANTIAL keeps that ass covered. Incidentally, this also applies to travel advisories, which are very quick to ratchet up the threat level and very slow to climb down.
- freeflight 6y ago> I think that no, they are flagging every day as having a terrorist attack "likely"! They indeed do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_Threat_Levels#Changes_to_threat_levels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_Threat_Levels#Changes_to_th...
- ATsch 6y agoIt is a pretty good technique for expanding police powers. You allow them to do more stuff, but only when the level is high enough. Nobody will object because objecting to emergency measures looks bad. Then, whenever something bad happens you just increase the threat level. When you reach the top, "reform" the system to add higher levels.
- hankchinaski 6y ago>”reform” the system to add highet levels when did this happen exactly?
- ATsch 6y agoI was thinking about the French "Vigipirate" system, which I think has "lowered" the threat level by defining higher levels at least two times now. For example I remember a few years ago, the second highest color level, red, was declared to be the now lowest level, "Vigilance". It has never been that low again since.
- javajosh 6y agoI think what it does is raise people's alertness levels for a while, until they regress back toward the mean. That threat level is like a volume knob you can use to make a whole society clench up, sweating out cortisol. I wonder how it is officially announced, and what the physical causal chain is from decision to wide distribution of volume knob state? I wonder how many of these there are, and how closely they are watched and anticipated, and if it wouldn't make a fun website to collect all of them together.
- OJFord 6y agoRightly or wrongly it has automatic effects on policies that track it, most obviously # bobbies on the beat around X location, etc.
- ponker 6y agoIt’s never gone below substantial because the UK would need to change a ton of things, which are politically, legally, and practically impossible to change, for the threat level to go below substantial.