4 ms·
I extremely do not want the situation where the state owns and operates the communications infrastructure of the general population. That's turnkey tyranny, ce
by sneak 6y ago
I extremely do not want the situation where the state owns and operates the communications infrastructure of the general population.
That's turnkey tyranny, censorship both ways (what you can send, what you can read). Right now it's just expensive, but you can still use a few different (overpriced and anti-competitive) providers.
If the state decides you're a threat and unplugs you, it could be months or years before you can invoke your legal rights to get reinstated.
- xnyan 6y agoISPs give the US government absolutely anything they want. You have no real protection from the government because of private ownership, the only difference is now both private organizations AND the government make decisions about your internet access. You also pay more for less vs most countries with more regulated infrastructure or state owned infrastructure. I'm happy to look at any evidence you have, but everything I have seen indicates US internet is vastly worse than more public-oriented systems, unless you own internet infrastructure.
- sneak 6y agoYes, but if the state is the only game in town, you can't pop down to the next shop and buy a new SIM card, or order an install from a different provider.
- beaunative 6y agoOwning the infrastructure (the cell towers, fiber lines) is not the same as operating a network, the infrastructure could be public owned, while the service provider operating in data centers that connects to those public owned infrascture for a cost.
- rayhendricks 6y agoMunicipal broadband where the county PUD owns the fiber and multiple private companies provide service over them works great. Which is why you can get gigabit internet for like $50 some places and struggle to get decent internet in the suburbs. Also Comcast is not going to tell the federal government "no" to a data request if it doesn't benifit them.
- cyberdrunk 6y agoThe State owns USPS and it's not so bad. Before phones were introduced, it was the main channel of communication.
- michaelt 6y agoSome would take USPS as a demonstration of the state delivering a communication service with fair performance and competitive prices. Others would take the USPS as proof that a strongman president can switch such services on and off at a whim, for political reasons.
- cyberdrunk 6y ago> Others would take the USPS as proof that a strongman president can switch such services on and off at a whim, for political reasons. When was it done?
- gumby 6y agoThis is why in most countries, phone systems were developed and run by the post office. I don’t think it worked out well. I am supportive of municipal telecom infrastructure but this example always gives me pause.
- sneak 6y agoThe state currently performs suspicionless surveillance on the entire traffic graph of the USPS. Every piece of mail is weighed and imaged and sender anf recipient are placed into a database, so it is impossible to send a letter without creating a permanent record of source and destination. You can, of course, leave off the return address, and this works fine for letter mail. Packages, however, require ID to be dropped off. You cannot use the USPS to send packages anonymously. The analogous version for a state-run ISP would be a blanket filter/ban on Tor/VPN usage. I don’t think the USPS is a good example of a state-run organization for that reason. The state has already demonstrated their desire to eradicate personal privacy and anonymity.
- Broken_Hippo 6y ago*If the state decides you're a threat and unplugs you, it could be months or years before you can invoke your legal rights to get reinstated." You've heard of no-fly lists, right? At least there are some protections with governments, in general. With private companies, not only do you get the risk from the government, but whatever censorship the ISP decides to subject you to as well, and you might not have a choice. Luckily, there are some ways around some of the controls - in no small part, by doing regulation or allowing a hybrid system (government owns/maintains infrastructure, leases it to companies, for example)
- sneak 6y agoThere was a period of years between when the no-fly list was instituted and when there was a system of relief for people who were placed on it erroneously. This is really just supporting my point that you do NOT want the government involved in the system at all. You still can’t get off of the no-fly list (even if you haven’t been convicted of a crime!) if the government wants you on it and you weren’t listed by accident, “redress number” program or no. Let’s not fuck up ISPs this badly.
- usefulcat 6y agoAre you sure that having privately owned and operated communications infrastructure will actually prevent any of the things you're concerned about? For example, AT&T rolled right over when the government wanted more access to their infrastructure after 9/11, even though it was pretty clearly illegal.