3 ms·
It actually wasn't a false dilemma either. His intent in the statement was to make the point that in the "war against terror", there aren't any neutrals. He did
by jerf 16y ago
It actually wasn't a false dilemma either. His intent in the statement was to make the point that in the "war against terror", there aren't any neutrals. He didn't consider it neutral to "passively" harbor terrorists, even if you didn't actively support them with resources; he was making the point that either you enforced laws against terrorist activities (and therefore had some in the first place) or you were part of the terrorism problem.
I'm not saying you have to agree or disagree with this, or that I particularly do. But this is not logically a false dilemma, where it accidentally or duplicitously leaves out a third option. It is a statement that in this case there is no meaningful third option. It may be false under your particular set of moral values, but it is/was not a logical fallacy.