7 ms·
Windows 7 won't die, still second most popular operating system
- devenblake 6y agoIf I was a multimillion dollar corporation trying to follow the best operating system I had made thus far (ignoring the splatter that was Windows 8 and 8.1) there are some things I wouldn't do: - introduce telemetry - introduce unnecessary updates and remove the ability to choose not to install them. security updates are fine, feature updates that break things but are only temporarily avoided are unacceptable. - remove theming. I would not remove the ability to use the themes my designers had created over the years. - introduce a "Settings" app that fragments the OS configuration (especially if my operating system already had a weird second settings menu that you could only get to by running a command like, for example, `msconfig`). If I did do these things, I would probably introduce them in a beta operating system and continue to support my flagship product because it would, in this hypothetical scenario, be much friendlier to the average user (whom in this scenario I target).
- java-man 6y agoit just tells us that the end users are not the customers. and those of us who actually paid $200 for windows 10, are too small of a section of the customers to be heard.
- ksk 6y agoThey already did all that with their enterprise edition, but they don't market it much. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_10_editions#Comparison_chart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_10_editions#Comparison... Even with the somewhat limited pro edition, our IT is able to give us months and months of uptime for certain critical computers (i'm in biotech). Heck we have a W10 pro machine that handles building security and it has over 2 years of uptime. The problem is the disconnect between HN and the average user who is dumb as rocks when it comes to tech. The average user expects the OS to magically take over the sysadmin duties. They just want it to be as simple and seamless as their phone - not an entirely unreasonable expectation given that the phone is sharing a lot of tasks that were only done on dedicated machines.
- zaphirplane 6y agoKind of funny to say the security machine hasn’t been patched for 2 years Yeah I know it’s badges not mission impossible security
- White_Wolf 6y agoFor isolated machines it's not uncommon. The process to re-approve a machine after a bloody update is painful(to say the least). Even for something as lousy as a BMS system of a reasonable size (100 bacnet controller) will still take 1 week or more to fully test and approve. Keep in midn that these are machine where the only things that you can plug in are those whitelisted at the end of the test. Even the approval to replace a keyb+mouse set takes a few days and requires a sys admin to go to site.
- ksk 6y agoHeh, Yes on re-reading the comment it does sound ironic. :) Our IT is not purposely keeping a security hole open to boast about uptime. If there was a security impact to our particular configuration/use-case, we'd patch it for sure.
- xnyan 6y agoI would argue that the telemetry, updates and theming are not major concerns for Windows customers because they can be addressed or simply don’t care, but I can see your point of view and in my opinion are legitimate (though not unique) downsides to windows. I’m actually impressed with Microsoft’s dedication to unify decades of settings UI/Ux. it’s a commendable goal, and while I don’t deny I have had to lookup how to do something in the “new” way many times, I believe it’s worth in and end the end will result in a more logical and consistent configuration interface.
- jerry80 6y agoThe problem is that they haven't unified decades of settings. They further fragmented the settings and made everything much worse. There are still many things you simply cannot do with the new settings app. Now there's several different places (control panel, settings app, policy editor, etc) you need to look to get any configuration changes done - and the next Windows update will probably revert your changes anyway! It's pretty user-hostile at this point.
- WorldMaker 6y agoMost of the settings reverts ars bugs not caught by Insiders. A volunteer test force is always going to be biased by the types of people willing to participate. Personally, since a major Windows update or two ago I only have one settings panel I actively use that is still a Win32 dialog and not directly in the modern Settings app. That's the Environment Variables dialog, and being a developer/power user control panel I can see how that would be a lower priority to merge to the new Settings. Though it is still interesting to point out that the Environment Variables dialog was improved in Windows 10 over its Windows 7 counterpart. It shouldn't be surprising to anyone at this point that Microsoft is prioritizing settings updates and merging settings dialogs into the modern app in priority order based on available telemetry of what's most commonly used. It never surprises me that most of the people still complaining that their pet settings that they care about haven't migrated to the modern Settings apps are the same that disable telemetry and complain about it. Microsoft doesn't know you are using that setting often if you aren't giving them the telemetry to understand that, it's pretty simple.
- 908B64B197 6y agoI keep hearing about telemetry but how bad is it really? Doesn't macOS collects some as well?
- WorldMaker 6y agoI think it's very similar what macOS collects and what Windows does these days. I don't know if macOS has a tool like this, but anyone curious exactly what telemetry Windows is collect, Microsoft provides a Diagnostic Data Viewer tool to explore it: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy/diagnostic-data-viewer-overview https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy/diagnostic-... There's a ton of documentation at this point on everything Windows collects as telemetry. (Most of the same telemetry is in Windows 7, fwiw. A lot of the telemetry systems were added in Vista or XP. The biggest change was Windows 10 turned on a lot more of it on by default rather than nagging people to join the various "Customer Experience Improvement Programs" and consolidating all those opt-in/opt-out "improvement programs" from a half-dozen different nag dialogs to a single privacy settings panel.)
- vetinari 6y agoMacOS asks you about it in the OOBE (you can change your decision later in the System Preferences) and then respects your decision. A novel concept, I know.
- m463 6y agoIt seems to me like poor diplomacy between two nations with a slight power imbalance. It should be about mutual trust and respect. I have more power, I will use it. I have less power, what can I do, I'll just have to accept it.
- dleslie 6y agoIf Windows 7 was still receiving regular DirectX updates, and similar, then there'd be no reason to switch to Windows 10. Windows 7 is a superior product in all other respects.
- throw7 6y agoDirectx is the only reason I'll be upgrading soon, otherwise I'm still booting into win 7 in another partition for a few old games, but i really want to play cyberpunk 2077 when it comes out so yeah...
- speeder 6y agoCyberpunk 2077 runs on Windows 7. Microsoft made DX12 work on Win7 for some games, Cyberpunk 2077 is one of them. They are not THAT dumb to waste a huge market. Source: https://www.gamepressure.com/newsroom/cyberpunk-2077-will-run-on-windows-7-even-on-dx-12/z21f6e https://www.gamepressure.com/newsroom/cyberpunk-2077-will-ru...
- throw7 6y agoWow. I had no idea. ha. yes.
- chaganated 6y agoTry running wireshark on windows 10 calculator.
- tootahe45 6y agoCan you explain?
- Lammy 6y ago"This project collects usage data and sends it to Microsoft to help improve our products and services. Read our privacy statement to learn more. Diagnostic data is disabled in development builds by default, and can be enabled with the SEND_DIAGNOSTICS build flag."
- gao8a 6y agoI guess Google and now Microsoft know I can't do basic math :(
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- grovellogic 6y agoIsn't it all MIT license OpenSource: https://github.com/microsoft/calculator https://github.com/microsoft/calculator Can't we just strip all the BS from it, and make our own version?
- liquidify 6y agoWindows 7 is faster and more stable for me than Windows 10 has been. I am forced to keep a drive around with it so that I can run audio recording applications without glitches. I have tried every optimization point that I am aware of, but latency mon shows a variety of problem in Win 10, most prominently with NDIS.sys. None of those problems exist in Windows 7 for me. It just works for music and it works cleanly without problems, just as it has since I first installed it. Using GRUB makes it easy to maintain multiple OS's, but it sure would be better if Windows 10 didn't have the problems that it does.
- CydeWeys 6y agoWindows 7 was definitely the peak Microsoft desktop experience. Windows 8 was a trash fire of a tablet OS (no matter what Microsoft might say otherwise, that's what it was) that I was fortunate enough never to have to experience first-hand on any of my devices, but that I did have enough experience with secondhand to see how bad it is. Windows 10 is better than 8, but that's a very low bar, and it's still worse than 7. Windows 10 has an absolute garbage mess of different configuration windows, some that look several decades old but at least are usable and some that have clearly been redesigned recently but which you can't find anything in. USB peripherals can either mount as drivers or as something called a "Device" (even if all they're really doing is mounting as a drive), and the latter is completely unintuitive and nearly impossible to figure out how to unmount safely. File/application finding is a still a dumpster fire that never works for me. There's garbage Cortana integrated into the start menu that always seems to want to search the web via Bing (???!?!!), but can't reliably find files or locally installed applications, even by exact name match. If I wanted to search the Web I'd be searching in a Web browser! Hell, even searching files by exact name or name prefix in the Finder search window just flat out doesn't work. I don't understand how Windows 10 managed to get such fundamentals so completely broken. I find that desktop Linux is actually more usable than Windows 10 simply because basic features like file search actually just work. Unfortunately Windows still wins on compatibility with applications (and especially games) so I'm stuck with it, but if I could run everything I wanted on my Linux computer I'd ditch my Windows computer in a heartbeat.
- 6y ago
- marta_morena_28 6y agoThe only reason why I even still have to use windows is because of Adobe Lightroom. But perhaps I will look for alternatives. There is literally no other reason anymore. Microsoft has ruined their operating system.
- ksk 6y agoI'm sure you already know it, but Lightroom works on OSX too. And also I believe Adobe Camera Raw can bulk-convert your camera-specific RAWs to DNGs, which you can use in any software - unless you need lens profiles. I'm trying to wean myself off the Adobe subscription treadmill and giving Affinity Photo a try. Seems decent so far.
- LinuxBender 6y agoI keep a Windows 7 machine for World of Warcraft. I will never update it. It is not even fully patched, to avoid the nagging patches. I update Defender, that's it. I don't run untrusted code so that isn't an issue. Some day I will have to get Win10 for a newer machine, but it will be LTSC. LTSC should be able to play games just fine and is what the default Windows 10 should have been, in my opinion. I will have to get a really beefy machine to compensate for the extra bloat in the Windows 10 kernel. I am not at all impressed with how Microsoft handled Windows 10. One would assume that with all the telemetry, they would have a solid highly optimized OS by now. This is not the case. A family member has nothing but problems with Windows 10 + VR + games, etc... I have identical hardware and have none of their issues.
- xscott 6y agoBlizzard games, including WoW and Overwatch, run very well under Linux using Wine if you use Lutris to get the configuration right.
- LinuxBender 6y agoIts been quite a while since I tried playing WoW in wine. I've heard it has improved a lot. I will give it a shot at some point.
- interestica 6y agoScrolling the file tree in Windows Explorer in W10 is slow depending on the pane width. This is insane to me. Base issues like that just didn't seem to be around in W7
- michaelbrave 6y agoA good example of how Windows 7 worked better is Skyrim, in windows 10 it has a memory cap of about 4 gigs while in windows 7 it doesn't. If you run a ton of mods and you know that we do this presents a situation where technically windows 7 runs things better.
- Hallucinaut 6y agoDo you have a reference for that, because it just sounds like someone's running a 32-bit version somewhere?
- michaelbrave 6y agoI went to look it up and it seems windows 10 patched a fix in Windows 10 v1709. So I guess my info was outdated, apologies.
- yuhong 6y agoI deliberately installed the updates that contain CompatTelRunner and Appraiser on an old Windows 7 laptop with a hard drive to demonstrate its problems. I had to set a registry value before it actually consumed CPU and HDD time though. In fact, nxquery.sys is targeted at Windows 7 users (it is a simple driver to read a MSR to determine if NX is disabled in the BIOS). Trivia: Appraiser creates multiple threads, so it is not just one core that consumes CPU time.
- Nginx487 6y agoWindows 7 is objectively the best operating system MS ever done, the most stable, secure and having the most comfortable user experience. Highly promoted Windows 10 leaves rotten smell for every technically educated user. First thing you have to do is remove all crapware, preinstalled despite you paid for your OS. Then you probably should harden your privacy by disabling all telemetry features. When I forced to use Windows 10, first application I run is ShutUp10 [0], then I disable Cortana and block telemetry servers using simple script [1], which may be outdated, because I did not touch 10 for some time. For personal purposes I use hardened Windows 7 inside Parallels, and hope to keep this configuration as long as possible. I suggested hardening guide post [2] (pdf) on HN, but few people were interested. Hope it would help someone though . [0] https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10 https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10 [1] https://github.com/yuchdev/windows_10_antispy https://github.com/yuchdev/windows_10_antispy [2] https://www.cyber.gov.au/sites/default/files/2019-11/PROTECT%20-%20Hardening%20Microsoft%20Windows%207%20SP1%20Workstations%20%28November%202019%29.pdf https://www.cyber.gov.au/sites/default/files/2019-11/PROTECT...
- simonblack 6y agoTidier, cleaner more rational layout and work-flow than 8 or 10. (OK. More "traditional" if you like.) Every time I try to use 8 or 10, I seem to spend ages just trying to find what I want. I don't boot Windows very often, but when I do, I try to make sure that it's Windows 7.