4 ms·
where the intent is simply to show that an argument or statement is wrong in all particulars That is neither a behavior nor an objective consistent with respec
by brudgers 6y ago
where the intent is simply to show that an argument or statement is wrong in all particulars
That is neither a behavior nor an objective consistent with respectful didactic discussion — even should the initial position be presented as an enumerated list. Without finding common ground good faith is missing. It’s a you and the horse you rode. An exchange of ordinance not ideas.
It’s winning not learning.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe intent of fisking in this context isn't based on the notion of trying to present an argument of arguable validity as wrong. The intent is to expose an utterly fallacious argument for what it is. Impeaching a witness, as it were (though this can also be more concisely achieved generally). Where there is in fact no common ground or intent to establish such by the counterparty, common ground cannot be found. Keep in mind that the extremity of this practice is precisely why I suggest practicing it rarely.
- brudgers 6y agoRationalizing one’s behavior “because they deserve it” is the basis of bullying and antithetical to respectful dialogue. Finding one’s self in situations where utter fallaciousness is perceived and arguing in its face requires a lot of deliberate choice. The arguing not least among them. To be fallacious, reasoning must draw an incorrect conclusion from undisputed premises. For example x -> y x ergo k Fallacious reasoning doesn’t require point by point rebuttal. It’s all at the truth table. Fallacious reasoning is the application of the wrong truth table. Facts in dispute are orthogonal to fallacy. Incorrect conclusions based upon suspect premises are not fallacious. They are simply normal human fallibility. The pick apart requires deliberate incharitable interpretation and great effort to avoid common ground. The “utterly” in “utterly fallacious” belies the veracity of any claim to respectfulness.
- dredmorbius 6y agoYou're entirely mischaracterising my comments.