4 ms·
> For example: the government paid ISPs $400 billion dollars (!) to create a nationwide fiber network False: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556 http
by rayiner 6y ago
> For example: the government paid ISPs $400 billion dollars (!) to create a nationwide fiber network
False: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556
- thotsBgone 6y agoIt wasn't in taxes or tax breaks, but the ISPs were given exemption to regulation on prices in exchange for deploying a fiber network they never deployed. This basically happened twice, which is why I talk about 400 billion when the link you gave only talks about the first 200. https://www.natoa.org/events/BrokenPromisesGarcia.pdf https://www.natoa.org/events/BrokenPromisesGarcia.pdf BTW the logic in your link doesn't make sense. The $200 billion number is "based on taking what ISP profits would have been had they been regulated as a utility", yes, but the only reason we didn't regulate them as a utility is they promised us the fiber networks!
- rayiner 6y agoIs there a way to have a discussion where we use words according to their ordinary meaning? You said "the government paid ISPs $400 billion dollars." As you acknowledge, money didn't change hands. So nothing was "paid" right? The government deregulated prices in 1996 for the same reason we deregulated airline fares, truck tariffs, etc. The government wanted to get out of the business of price control. And it didn't just happen in the U.S., it happened all over the world. Fiber was presented as a benefit that would result from increased capital investment following deregulation. And that happened to an extent--wireline capital expenditure almost doubled from 1996-2001. But after 2000, capital started moving to the fast-growing industry of cellular wireless, where the returns were better. So yeah, we didn't get as much investment in fiber as we expected. But we got huge investments in cellular. That's how free markets work--the government can't predict or direct where capital goes. The 1996 telecom deregulation wasn't a bargain, where ISPs were allowed to raise prices in exchange for a "promise" to build fiber. It was a deregulation of the industry. It's fair to complain that maybe the benefits of deregulation were oversold. (I can also claim that projections about premiums reductions under Obamacare have been oversold!) I think the 1996 deregulation should have been paired with a preemption of state-and-local broadband construction regulation. (American municipalities regulate in a way that makes it expensive to build infrastructure, whether you're talking about broadband or subway tunnels.) In particular, the nearly universal requirement to agree to service an entire city in exchange for permission to service any part of a city vastly limits the competition that could have been enabled by deregulation. Its fair to have a debate about the ultimate outcomes of the 1996 deregulation. But its deceitful to act like it was a planned government fiber-construction project where ISPs just "pocketed the money" and didn't build the infrastructure.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoFrom Bruce Kushnick, himself: "I've been tracking the telco deployments of fiber optics since 1991 when they were announced as something called the Information Superhighway. The plan was to have America be the first fiber optic country -- and each phone company went to their state commissions and legislatures and got tax breaks and rate increases to fund these 'utility' network upgrades that were supposed to replace the existing copper wires with fiber optics -- starting in 1992. And it was all a con. As a former senior telecom analyst (and the telcos my clients) i realized that they had submitted fraudulent cost models, and fabricated the deployment plans. The first book, 1998, laid out some of the history "The Unauthorized Bio" with foreword by Dr. Bob Metcalfe (co-inventor of Ethernet networking). I then released "$200 Billion Broadband Scandal" in 2005, which gave the details as by then more than 1/2 of America should have been completed -- but wasn't. And the mergers to make the companies larger were also supposed to bring broadband-- but didn't. I updated the book in 2015 "The Book of Broken Promises $400 Billion broadband Scandal and Free the Net", but realized that there were other scams along side this -- like manipulating the accounting."
- tptacek 6y agoSince Bruce Kushnick is one of the originators of this "$200 Billion Broadband Scandal" claim, I'm not sure what simply quoting him does for this discussion. We all agree that there are people making this claim; what seems dubious is that the claim is valid.
- kushnick 6y agoYou might want to read one of the trilogy of books we wrote on the subject, the first published in 1998, the latest published in 2015, or the collection of research reports we published as New Networks and now the IRREGULATORS, our consortium of lawyers, forensic auditors and other analysts, the last book, http://irregulators.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/BookofBrokenPromises.pdf http://irregulators.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/BookofBro... and our library of research http://irregulators.org/our-work-reports-filings/ http://irregulators.org/our-work-reports-filings/ Moreover, the books and research not only use the expertise of our gang (or which some of us have been working together for a few decades) but, we quote primary research, such as annual reports, state and federal filings by AT&T et al, etc, much of which are hidden in plain sight, such as the Verizon NY 2019 Annual Report, which is the financial report of the primary telecommunications state-based public utility-- and ironically most reading this don't even know that there are still state public utilities left. http://irregulators.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Verizonny2019annualcomplete.pdf http://irregulators.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Verizonny... The $200 billion broadband scandal was published in 2005 and that was based on examining the state-based commitments for fiber upgrades and the changes in state laws that gave the companies billions per state to do the upgraded-- i.e., rate increases and tax breaks. The most recent work uncovered that the accounting has been manipulated in the utilities and caused the networks to appear unprofitable --- and we're preparing to take legal actions in multiple states-- it's about $20 billion annually in the US. https://bit.ly/3mQUWgf https://bit.ly/3mQUWgf As a former senior telecom analyst to the telcos 1982-1994--we knew were the skeletons were buried...so, we didn't just 'wing it', and the books detail our claims. So while others may follow in our footsteps... we've been at this for decades with actual documentation to substantiate our work. to see the latest, I post at medium. https://kushnickbruce.medium.com/ https://kushnickbruce.medium.com/
- FireBeyond 6y agoWeren't you an attorney for a telco lobbying organization? Seems like that's a relevant disclosure, no?
- tptacek 6y agoComments like this aren't allowed on HN; see the Guidelines below.
- FireBeyond 6y agoIs it an insinuation when the user themselves has stated, on multiple occasions, that this exactly the case?
- tptacek 6y agoYes, you straight-up aren't allowed to post like this: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=author%3Adang%20personal%20details&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... Even stipulating that your comment had some kind of probative value, the cost to the community of people routinely pulling this shit far outstrips that value; accusations of bad-faith commenting are one of the most corrosive forces on message boards. Demanding users not make those accusations is one of the things HN gets uniquely right.