13 ms·
Seriously, I feel like I say it every time it comes up: WHY aren't people taking action against ISP monopolies? It seems like such a cut-and-dried political is
by crazygringo 6y ago
Seriously, I feel like I say it every time it comes up: WHY aren't people taking action against ISP monopolies?
It seems like such a cut-and-dried political issue: they're utilities and they overcharge you whether you're a Republican or Democrat. And taking action doesn't require new antitrust concepts, because it's just your garden-variety utility. It's the same established principles as electric or natural gas.
Yet bizarrely this doesn't show up as an issue on Republican or Democrat platforms. Going after Google and Amazon and Facebook's free products is the sexy new issue, but the fact that we're all overpaying hundreds of dollars a year for broadband is just massively ignored.
And I'm not talking about politicians being bought. It baffles me why voters aren't writing letters to their city councils, their mayors, their state reps, their governors. If voters actually care, politicians do respond.
It would seriously be so easy to change if the voting population actually did care about it. But, inexplicably, we just pay the fees and deal with the crappy customer service and complain, but it never seems to occur to anybody to actually organize local political action against it.
It's utterly baffling.
- burlesona 6y agoIt's a good question, but I think one of the issues is that physical networks are a natural monopoly in the same way as most public utilities, so it's not just about enabling more competition but about establishing a regulatory framework around that competition, much like exists with airports and railways. OR, alternatively, changing to a public sector provision model like plumbing or roads. What actually bothers me the most is the rules that (in most places) prohibit cities and towns from offering new municipal broadband service as a competitive offering. This used to be more common in smaller towns that had not been able to get good commercial service, and it adds valuable options and competition, but my understanding is that it's extremely hard for cities who don't already have municipal broadband to start offering it now.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoLocal Loop Unbundling works fine in the UK
- techsupporter 6y agoAnd worked pretty well[0] for the seven or so glorious years we had it in the United States before the Bush FCC ended it. 0 - Yes, I know, it wasn't perfect or even "great" most of the time but that was largely because the incumbent carriers dragging their feet on doing literally anything and the FCC not enforcing the competition rules. And when, largely out of spite, the copper-based incumbents simply didn't do anything to upgrade their networks while the not-at-all-regulated cable companies blew past them in speed and reliability, people switched in droves which gave the incumbent phone companies even more reason to throw up their hands and say "not worth it."
- thatfrenchguy 6y agoI mean, if it's a natural monopoly, then it should be public. Roads aren't private right ?
- milkytron 6y agoNot all roads are public. Many toll roads are actually privately owned by the toll company.
- patmorgan23 6y agoMost toll roads are actually public but then under a management contract with a private party for toll collection/enforcement.
- nostromo 6y agoI'd compare it to utilities like PG&E or ConEd. These are private companies. But since they're considered natural monopolies, they are more highly regulated than a typical company.
- tshaddox 6y agoAnd that has not worked out well for PG&E. Or rather, for its customers. I'm sure its executive team is doing fine.
- polynomial 6y agoSome are.
- treis 6y ago>physical networks are a natural monopoly in the same way as most public utilities But ISPs are not, generally speaking, a monopoly. There's usually at least two wired options and they compete with cellular and satellite options. Profit margins generally reflect this. The large ISPs are around the average for the S&P 500.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoLow latency, low packet loss, high upload and download bandwidth, unmetered internet service is certainly a monopoly. None of this is possible with wireless. You're lucky if you live in a place with symmetric gigabit fiber service. There's only one provider. And quite frankly, there's no need to string multiple fibers to every house. Everyone else has a subpar coaxial connection from Comcast/Cox/Spectrum.
- treis 6y agoIf you segment any market enough eventually you end up with a monopoly. And your segment is unreasonable. Very very few people need symmetric gigabit fiber. Using that as the criteria is like saying Lamborghini has a monopoly on cars because they're the only one that makes one that goes 200 mph.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIf you're laying fiber, it costs next to nothing to make it gigabit versus 10Mbit. The issue is that fiber internet itself is a much better product than non fiber internet. And tell the people who have kids and are also working from home that they can't stream video because an HD video stream is 3Mbps+ and 4 people in a house streaming at the same time at high quality is basically impossible. Some people also have security cameras streaming upload too. The applications for increased bandwidth are numerous. Remote doctor visits can use high quality video, you can stream things from your home NAS, backups are quicker.
- gnopgnip 6y ago>There's usually at least two wired options Per https://www.fcc.gov/internet-access-services-reports https://www.fcc.gov/internet-access-services-reports approximately only about 25% of census blocks have two or more providers for wired internet. Often within a census block most households will only have one option.
- WalterBright 6y ago> one of the issues is that physical networks are a natural monopoly When telephones were first installed, competing telephone companies stringing wires sprang up everywhere. Regulation put a stop to that.
- rapsey 6y agoIt’s only baffling if you believe the system works. It is entirely unsurprising if you believe that those monopolies are too rich and powerful to be attacked by politicians.
- avmich 6y agoSo the question becomes then why people believe so much this - "that those monopolies are too rich and powerful to be attacked by politicians" - to not act, while they, the same people, don't seem to have similar beliefs in other issues.
- pydry 6y agoUsually because it's also in the interests of a powerful group who piggybacks off popular support for an issue for their own purposes. Net neutrality was a good example of this - still good despite not being the most important issue du jour. Received attention because it's coincidentally in the interests of Google et al.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> WHY aren't people taking action against ISP monopolies? Mainly because ISPs are not engaging in viewpoint discrimination. They don’t care what political viewpoint you have, as long as you pay them money, they will let you post it on the internet. In addition, most people have become used to the prices and expending a bunch of political energy to save $30/month isn’t worth it to a lot of people. Now the feeling of being censored, on the other hand, generates a visceral reaction, and people can be convinced to expend a lot of political capital for that.
- nitrogen 6y agoOne could argue that ISPs participated in the fight against peer-to-peer technologies, the hindrance of which allowed social media and other communication technologies to centralize.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pixl97 6y agoOnly baffling because you dont fully comprehend how much communication monopolies control they playing field by financing both political parties. Not behind my computer, but look up the legal bribery that has prevented municipal broadband in the US. I worked for Cox when this was a thing back in the early 2000s. There is no amount of money they would not spend to subvert competition.
- AlexandrB 6y agoISPs are "natural monopolies" like water or electrical companies, especially in areas with low density. This means that even a level playing field was not enough, because small competitors can't afford the cost of building their own infrastructure (nor would we want them to lay redundant cables). Measures like Net Neutrality are ways of keeping the natural monopolies from abusing their position to gain advantage in other markets. Here Biden clearly seems to be for net neutrality while Trump is, obviously, against it. So it's not as if this issue is not visible to both candidates. It's just never spoken about in terms of "monopoly" because there's no clear way to eliminate natural monopoly without a ton of regulation (e.g. sharing the last mile) or outright public takeover of the last mile infrastructure.
- thotsBgone 6y agoThis is the result of government corruption. For example: the government paid ISPs $400 billion dollars (!) to create a nationwide fiber network, and the ISPs pocketed the money and didn't do it. No investigation into what happened or anything. The money is just gone. Clearly corruption is the only explanation. Politicians have been bought. Why voters don't know/care is another issue, but it might have something to do with the fact that the news media has also been bought.
- colejohnson66 6y agoIt’s really down to the simple fact that most people aren’t aware. And those that are feel powerless to do anything about it; “It’s been this way for so long, it’s part of how life is now.” (see also: the NSA spying complex) Not to mention that ISP monopolies aren’t near the top of people’s “policy priority list”(TM) (contrast with, say, abortion), so even if a politician were to campaign to fix the problem, most people wouldn’t care. And because of that, most candidates don’t campaign that much about ISPs because it’s (essentially) a waste of ad money. Take Ron Wyden (D-OR) for example. He’s been talking about the problems of “Big Tech,”[a] the NSA, etc. for years, but no one outside tech or his state have even heard of him. [a]: Those aren’t “scare quotes.” They’re because there isn’t really a good word for it. FAANG seems too restrictive compared to how many companies are actually part of the problem.
- thotsBgone 6y agoMost people aren't aware... why? I'd guess because the media is controlled by some of the same people who want us to remain unaware. They block information from reaching the media, and flood media with sensationalist stories to prevent attention from settling on issues that matter.
- rayiner 6y ago> For example: the government paid ISPs $400 billion dollars (!) to create a nationwide fiber network False: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7709556
- havetocharge 6y agoCan't be hurting the domestic spying apparatus.
- furyofantares 6y ago> Yet bizarrely this doesn't show up as an issue on Republican or Democrat platforms. The cynic in me says that it's because it helps neither win against the other.
- sumtechguy 6y agowatching them flip positions in realtime was quite interesting too. neither group cares because of what you say, and money, but mostly money. i became 100% convinced neither side really cared other than how much ended up as campaign contributions. all of the large cities at this point should have amazing internet. instead many dont or only small pockets of it. one side tells me how too many of them would make our roads a potmarked hellscape. the other tells me how they are being downtroden upon and throttled yet find new and inventive ways to spy on me. I am beginning to think it is time to declare shenanigans.
- jariel 6y agoIt's not baffling, it's populism. Only so many issues can be discussed at once in the commons and politicians are mostly going to react to those. So BLM, Facebook, Twitter, the Election, Trump etc. are sucking up all the air and that's that. There are other ugly factors: CNN is owned by AT&T. So do you think CNN is going to help 'fan the flames' of the movement? I don't think so. 'Anti Trust' is also a complicated word, almost a little to complicated for MSM cable news. It's possible for watchers to understand 'Privacy and Facebook' but it's a struggle to get the plebes to try to think about such an abstraction as 'anti trust'. Those entities spend a fortune lobbying both sides of congress. Without some popular focus and the press latching onto it like they did BLM, it's going to be hard to get some kind of movement going there. Even politicians that 'care' about the issue are going to want to 'pick their battles' and it might not be a while before someone starts knocking on that door.
- cortesoft 6y agoThis is a classic example of what happens when you have concentrated benefits and diffuse costs. Everyone pays a little bit more because of the way broadband is treated, but broadband companies make a LOT because of it. It simply doesn't reach a high enough priority for people to really push for reform, but it is high enough priority to broadband companies that they fight tooth and nail.
- muststopmyths 6y agoIt's only baffling if you didn't bother to read the party platforms. The Democratic party platform explicitly talks about removing barriers to municipal broadband as a goal, which is the only way you are going to get competition where ISPs have a monopoly. At least in the current landscape where it's cost-prohibitive for a competitor to enter a region. Also (emphasis mine), > Democrats will restore the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) clear authority to take strong enforcement action against broadband providers who violate net neutrality principles through blocking, throttling, paid prioritization, or other measures that create artificial scarcity and raise consumer prices for this vital service. Regardless of anyone's feelings broadband is not categorized as a utility. You may want it classified as such. Then ask yourself which party is likely to move in that direction. https://www.demconvention.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/2020-07-31-Democratic-Party-Platform-For-Distribution.pdf https://www.demconvention.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/202...
- briandear 6y ago> removing barriers to municipal broadband as a goal, which is the only way you are going to get competition Municipal broadband is the only way you’ll get competition? A “public option” seems to invite the very opposite of competition. Less regulation is how you increase competition — by allowing more new entrants into a market, you necessarily increase competition. Municipalities should own the wire, not the service flowing through the wire. Making capital expenditures less expensive would encourage more service providers.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoMunicipal broadband has been stopped predominantly by long term exclusivity contracts that were locked in by local politicians in the past. How would another option decrease competition? In what world does that make sense? This isn't without precedent. In markets where there are municipal broadband or increased competition in general, companies like AT&T immediately up their speeds, cut their prices, cut their contract lengths, etc.
- rayiner 6y ago> The Democratic party platform explicitly talks about removing barriers to municipal broadband as a goal, which is the only way you are going to get competition where ISPs have a monopoly. At least in the current landscape where it's cost-prohibitive for a competitor to enter a region. It's only "cost-prohibitive for a competitor to enter a region" because of build-out requirements which are broadly supported by Democrats. I used to live in Baltimore, where Verizon wanted to come in and compete with Comcast. The city refused to let Verizon come in and compete. Then they put out an RFP that basically sought bids for ISPs to come in and provide universal service for free. Nobody took Baltimore up on the offer.
- briandear 6y agoAre we overpaying? I pay less in the US for fiber Internet than I paid in France for DSL. Can “overpaying” be quantified?
- CyberDildonics 6y agoAustralia has also had more expensive internet than many countries including the US. This is because they had a huge telecom monopoly that locked down the market for decades. Just because the same problem has happened in other places doesn't mean it isn't a problem.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoWikipedia says "Bouygues Telecom lowered the first price of standard triple-play offers to €20 in February 2015." Which is half the basic US DSL price
- Fellshard 6y agoBecause Net Neutrality was the angle that brings more money their way. Net Neutrality assumes the monopoly will stay, that no alternatives are available, and that top-down control is the best bet. If you focus on the monopoly instead, different ISPs could offer different advantages based on the consumer's requirements: gaming, video consumption, media upload, basic light browsing - you could tailor engineering costs to meet the needs of consumers, instead of one-size-fits-all baggage.
- nitrogen 6y agoOffering consumer-controlled latency prioritization doesn't violate net neutrality. Giving that control exclusively to the ISP, or to third parties who pay the ISP, does.
- est31 6y agoNet neutrality doesn't forbid you from offering+building low latency services (needed by gaming), or from offering+building symmetric internet connections (useful for media upload). "Basic browsing" can be implemented by just giving users a low bandwidth or weekly traffic quotas. Also, most of the difference in these services lies in the backbone, but that's not where most of the cost lies. The main cost is digging the last mile. Generally, having multiple ISPs put cables to your porch will n-fold their cost. Who's gonna pay for that in the end? You, the customer. It's best to have one ISP lay fiber cabling to your home and then have them rent it out to others, on terms set up by regulators in advance. Maybe that last mile ISP could even be publicly owned.
- joshAg 6y agoBecause america is so anti-socialist. No, seriously. And it's the same reason why PG&E does such a shit job of maintaining their infrastructure, too. Letting anyone tear up the street to run their own wires whenever they want isn't feasible. From a competitor perspective,that's super expensive and a massive capital investment, so any preexisting competitor with a large enough warchest could just lower their competing prices to drive the new competitor out of business. But from a municipal or society perspective, cable right of ways/culverts are already a constrained resource, and installation disrupts traffic and residents. So basically that last mile infrastructure is a great example of a natural monopoly. If it wasn't such a natural monopoly, a market could be a great solution for increasing ISP quality, but since it is a natural monopoly, market based solutions fall flat due to lack of competition. This is where the socialism bit comes in. If america were less anti-socialist, it would treat the last mile of wires like it treats public roads. It doesn't solve the natural monopoly issue, but it does solve the issue that ISP users have no means by which to get the ISP to improve service. Unlike, a private ISP whose only constituents are the shareholders, a governments constituents are the people being governed, so if they want a better ISP, they can vote for improving it through bonds or taxes or however they want to finance it. But that's socialist and america hates socialism, so instead state governments pass anti-municipal-ISP laws and/or municipal governments grant multi-decade-exclusive service contracts in exchange for the ISP deigning to maintain the infrastructure or promising to marginally improve it (but of course at a rate that never threatens their quarterly numbers).
- mistrial9 6y agoyes, and .. there was a time long ago in California when PG&E had a clear, engineering oriented management culture. In fact, great infrastructure was built and ran very reliably, for decades. But the times changed. There were relatively fewer 'grand challenge' engineering efforts, and far more day-to-day infrastructure and labor management, accounting and banking. Oh, lots of cash accumulation and cash flow control, too. A new set of PG&E leadership settled in -- bean counters and control-focused policy. The old engineers, for good reason, considered their "job well done" and went to play golf or whatever. The new management hid money, played hardball with sub-sub-contractors, and told old people on pensions to pay up, as business people tend to do.. source: attorney from the time of the Enron price crisis in California
- randyrand 6y agoat the same time I don't want a single government ISP controlling everything controlled by bureaucracy. At least today we have hundreds of small ISP companies, and at least a few big ones. Every time I move I consider who my ISP will be.
- nobody9999 6y ago>at the same time I don't want a single government ISP controlling everything controlled by bureaucracy. Firstly, most municipal broadband networks, either built or proposed, absolutely do not include ISP services. Rather, they provide last-mile/Fiber-to-the-premises infrastructure that comes back to an interconnection point where multiple ISPs can provide Internet access services to customers. This actually increases competition, because ISPs don't need to pull cable to every single customer in order to provide service. They just need the appropriate back-haul capacity to service those customers who sign on with them. This allows for more competition on price, features and customer service, not a "single government ISP."
- closeparen 6y agoMaybe because the actual antipathy towards Facebook and Google is about their role in discourse and electioneering; antitrust is just a weapon that happens to be nearby.
- TuringNYC 6y agoJust a decade ago, SMS messages in the US cost 10 to 25 cents per SMS. You also got charged for spam SMS. Prices were completely disjointed from the reality of underlying costs (zero for the telcos). My college CS professor gave senate testimony on this: https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/keshav_testim https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/keshav_testim... (side rant: in the following ten years, the tech giants sweeped in, competed, provided a better service, with better cross-platform support, for zero dollar immediate cost to the end customer -- gained a massive following (think whatsapp), and are now vilified for their "monopoly" and the "harm" it has caused.) My read of this situation is: - Real monopolies (esp Telco) have entrenched lobbying bases - Tech has done a poor job at lobbying, possibly due to idealism that logic wins even though thats now how things work in the US - Tech has disrupted so much that they now have multiple industries as enemies - Tech is concentrated enough geographically that there is some jealousy against this sector "over there" raking in too much money, even if they have provided an amazing service
- arminiusreturns 6y agoK-Street runs congress, despite whatever their party platform talking points are. Non-representation in a captured legislative entrenched by things like gerrymandering maintain the status quo.
- imajoredinecon 6y ago> And I'm not talking about politicians being bought. It baffles me why voters aren't writing letters to their city councils, their mayors, their state reps, their governors. If voters actually care, politicians do respond. Concentrated benefits, disparate costs. Paying $20/month too much for internet is a pain in the ass, but it's a pretty minor issue for most people compared to (say) healthcare.