4 ms·
somehow saying >falling into the novelty trap by asserting things like “the internet has made transaction costs zero” — a sentence that would make any serious
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
somehow saying
>falling into the novelty trap by asserting things like “the internet has made transaction costs zero” — a sentence that would make any serious economist howl with laughter.
gets translated into
>the idea that the Internet has not had a massive impact on transactions costs.
- vmg1 6y agoI don't understand what you are trying to say here? Zero and near zero are effectively the same.
- sumtechguy 6y agoif the cost was 0 geocities would still be running.
- Jtsummers 6y agoNo, they aren't. "Zero" is zero, it means no cost. "Near zero" means some cost. Some cost, in aggregate, can easily become a major cost. Ever wonder why manufacturers of physical goods choose the component that's 1 penny less? Because that one penny can translate into millions in savings over the lifetime of a product. "Near zero" could translate into millions in costs over the lifetime of a product versus "zero".
- dasil003 6y agoThe discussion is around financial and market dynamics for different types of companies. Quibbling over the definition of zero vs near-zero is completely side-stepping the argument. The point is, for Google search variable costs are immaterial. This is not the case for any business that needs deals in physical inventory or human-provided services (which was the majority of businesses pre-Internet). Does Google incur some marginal infra costs from increased traffic or growth of the web? Yes. If you project out infinite growth does it become a "major cost"? No, the limit of profit over variable cost approaches zero.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>The point is, for Google search variable costs are immaterial..... >No, the limit of profit over variable cost approaches zero Ok well Google is an example, but the argument is about Internet companies not just Google, but ok Let's take Google and use that to go back to the more general level. aside from any other arguments - is it possible that variable cost approaches zero because Google is a monopoly with a high profit margin. If the profit were to decrease a lot from each transaction then they would be at a position where variable cost becomes more relevant. That is to say Google's special place has nothing to do with it being a magical internet company but rather its being in a seller's market that they dominate. If it were suddenly to no longer be in a seller's market or to have to do stuff like save data longer to get value from it, or to earn much less per search because advertisers didn't want to pay, or to find that there are side effects from having too much traffic that ends up decreasing ability to serve relevant data because of signal to noise ratio thus causing a loss of profit etc. etc. we would end up with the cost to Google of a transaction being much closer to what they earn from that transaction. In the last scenario I put up there, which I believe could actually be a problem if you project out infinite growth (search growth) does it become a "major cost", yes, in such a scenario too much traffic decreases the value of all traffic. In fact too much traffic decreasing the value of all traffic is a well known feature of Internet companies, because internet companies actually use physical devices (just wanted to point that out, since there seems to be this special thing about Internet companies not having physical inventory) to serve their customers or users (depending on which we're talking about here) and this is why DDOS is a thing and why even natural spikes in usage can be problematic. So in fact, I would actually say about just about any online company there is - if you project out infinite growth ( of traffic ) does it become a major cost? Um probably, and depending on how that a growth is structured it might in fact be a crippling cost.
- dasil003 6y agoBen Thompson explicitly states that he is not talking about all Internet companies, and that is one of his beefs with Tim Wu's critique—that it is reducing his actual argument to a caricature. To your point, yes I agree that this hinges on the specifics of Google's business. If, for example, their advertising business was made illegal in its current form it would completely change the economics.
- disown 6y ago> a sentence that would make any serious economist howl with laughter. A serious economist like Krugman who said the internet was going to have an impact on society no more than the fax machine? Or the serious economists who helped create the asian financial crisis? Or the serious economists who created the housing bubble? It almost seemed like you think society should care what "serious economists" think.
- jboog 6y agoCan't trust doctors because one time a doctor made a mistake! Flawless logic!
- TT3351 6y agoI hope we can both agree the standards of measurement for doctors and economists are not exactly comparable, given that one is just "is the patient better" and the other can be judged in any way imaginable. Is the economist macro, micro, do their solutions add to income inequality, or reduce it? The field of economics is clearly much more mercenary than the field of medicine.
- disown 6y agoOne time... Okay. Also, my dig wasn't at economists as individuals, but the pseudoscience called economics as a whole. There is a difference between a "mistake" like oops gave you the wrong medicine by accident and a pseudoscience like chinese medicine. And the internet prediction, asian financial crisis, housing bubble, etc aren't "mistakes"? It's just shows "serious economists" are just charlatans. The priests of modern era.
- 6510 6y agoYou are being to harsh on chinese medicine. I like the way Richard Wollf put it: There is a reason economics and business school are separate buildings.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoEconomists make mistakes. Like any other science. Their uncertainty is larger than something like physics, but not large enough to be considered pseudoscience. In newspapers they’ll shoot their mouths, but in their journals, they’re quite scientific. Your criticisms kinda remind me of data science work, where you say “the effect of doing this will probably be between -3 and +7, assuming X, Y, and Z, so it’s worth looking into.” Which PMs (like politicians) take as 2 (+/- 5) and promise the rest of the org a gain of 2. Then we implement it and it comes out as -1 and you need a post mortem about how data scientists (economists) got it so wrong.
- magwa101 6y agoAgreed, Thompson misinterprets so he can make his point, constantly "aggregation theory" and massive cut and pastes of prior posts to prove that he's right. He's interesting but in terms of making his case when confronted, he is a little reactive not heavy metal and reflective.