3 ms·
Set aside the techie charm, and what's going on here? When Steve comes up to you and wants to sell you his SteveBucks, how much would you pay? Steve tells you
by jfengel 6y ago
Set aside the techie charm, and what's going on here?
When Steve comes up to you and wants to sell you his SteveBucks, how much would you pay? Steve tells you that SteveBucks are absolutely un-counterfeitable, which is great, but what are they good for?
The store doesn't accept SteveBucks. Even Steve won't buy SteveBucks; Steve is trying to sell SteveBucks.
Finally, Steve tells you that SteveBucks are a great investment: eventually, everybody is going to want SteveBucks so you should get them now. And somehow that argument gets traction, and everybody is buying SteveBucks... and not spending them, because SteveBucks are great investments.
Hearing that story, wouldn't you feel weird about SteveBucks? Would you want to get involved with them? Wouldn't you rather just introduce your own BobBucks, which are every bit as good (and every bit as useless) as SteveBucks?
BTC's main advantage over SteveBucks is memeage for techies. They're the first BTC miners because they have hardware just sitting around, so they got the first bitcoins free and really want them to be worth something. And bonus, BTC are independent of the government, which is great, because you're a rich techie libertarian and all the government does is get in your way (or a poor techie libertarian who will one day be a rich techie libertarian).
The crypto wizardry of blockchain is incredibly clever, but ultimately not really all that big an advantage over a simple transactional database. It's less centralized, to be sure, but at the end of the day it's a massive effort for a problem that doesn't really need to be solved. Most BTC transactions end up going through some wallet provider anyway.
It's a fiat currency without even a fiat, just the collective hallucination lacking even the dirt a nation stands on and its network of taxes and government spending that give fiat currencies their real value. Steve doesn't understand anything about economics, and it's grating to listen to him loudly declaiming on a topic he knows less than nothing about.
So perhaps what "rubs us guys the wrong way" is being baffled that some people are getting rich trading SteveBucks back and forth to each other without actually producing anything.