4 ms·
Printing money is a bad idea. You think we had it bad, check out what happened here: https://alphahistory.com/weimarrepublic/great-depression/ https://alphahis
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
Printing money is a bad idea.
You think we had it bad, check out what happened here: https://alphahistory.com/weimarrepublic/great-depression/ https://alphahistory.com/weimarrepublic/great-depression/
I seem to remember something else, rather alarming, that happened after that...
- VMG 6y agoMMT proponents will have a list of reasons why this will not happen with the USD (because it is a reserve currency etc) The arguments are unconvincing because the USD could lose that status.
- neilwilson 6y agoNothing to do with reserve status. Everything to do with a non-convertible floating rate currency. The same applies to the UK, Japan, Canada, Australia and the Eurozone among others.
- BenoitEssiambre 6y agoWhile printing money to the extent MMTs advocate is bad,lack of printing during financial crisis is off the scale bad. It puts a gridlock in the economy as everyone, businesses and and banks aggressively reduce real economic activity in favor of collectively hoarding government paper (money and bonds). As your own link explains: "Rather than ramping up spending, Bruning increased taxes to reduce the budget deficit. He then implemented wage cuts and spending reductions, an attempt to lower prices. Bruning’s policies were rejected by the Reichstag but the chancellor was backed by President Paul von Hindenburg, who in mid-1930 issued his policies as emergency decrees. Bruning’s measures failed and only contributed to increased unemployment and public suffering in 1931-32. They also revived government instability and bickering between parties in the Reichstag." Or from wikipedia: "From 1930 onwards, President Paul von Hindenburg used emergency powers to back Chancellors Heinrich Brüning, Franz von Papen and General Kurt von Schleicher. The Great Depression, exacerbated by Brüning's policy of deflation, led to a surge in unemployment.[8] In 1933, Hindenburg appointed Adolf Hitler as Chancellor with the Nazi Party being part of a coalition government."
- lasagnaphil 6y agoI though the Weimar Republic's hyperinflation wasn't simply because the country printed her own currency; the more specific problem was that they then used that printed currency to pay back war reparations from other countries. Because the money is only going out of the nation's borders and isn't used to grow its own economy, the currency of the nation is devalued and international exchange rates fall, leading to a catastrophic amount of inflation. One thing I heard Stephanie Kelton and other MMTers has always emphasized about MMT is that the main question of the theory isn't "Should we print the money?", but "HOW should we use the printed money?" The money-printing is already conceptually independent from yearly budgets; the big question is how we're going to use that money so that uncontrollable inflation does not occur (which the Keynesians failed to answer with stagflation). If the newly printed money improves the strength of the "actually existing" national economy, then its currency will become competitive with others and a hyperinflation moment like Weimar would probably not happen.
- newacct583 6y ago1. Hyperinflation isn't the cause of Nazi Germany, please keep the Godwin goblins under the control. 2. Hyperinflation isn't a natural result of regular inflation. There have been countless governments that have engaged in deliberately inflationary policies. Basically none of them resulted in a hyperinflation spiral. 3. Hyperinflation isn't even caused by spending policies in the first place! It is the result of a collapse in national revenue, forcing a government to print money to honor debts that it can't otherwise pay. This leads to a collapse in confidence in the currency, and more printing, thus the spiral. I'm not aware of any nation anywhere that "printed money" for new spending and ended up in a hyperinflation state. You have a counterexample?
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoFair 'nuff. However, I lived in Africa. One of my best friends (at the time) lived in Zimbabwe. I lived in Uganda (I think that nation made the news, as well). There's another country that has had a hyperinflation problem: Venezuela (I think it's still going on). When you have to use a wheelbarrow to carry money to buy a loaf of bread, then something ain't right. Hyperinflation doesn't cause despots, but good old-fashioned misery for the masses goes a long way towards it. It's really easy to be clinical and analytical, when we don't have to pay the price, ourselves, but I can tell you, from personal experience, that walking past psychotic young men, carrying loaded machine guns, backed by the government, every day, kinda sucks. A lot of people in the world have to do exactly that. The one issue that I have with the tech social media scene, is how divorced we become from simple, basic humanity. Everything becomes strawmen and examples.
- neilwilson 6y agoBad pilots crash planes. That doesn't mean that heavier than air flight is impossible. It means you need better informed and trained pilots. See http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=3773 http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=3773 for the true story about Weimar.